Classical Music Home

The World's Leading Classical Music Group

Email Password  
Not a subscriber yet?
Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Christopher Abbot
Fanfare, March 2011


I reviewed these concert performances for Fanfare when they were first released (Beethoven in 33:1 and Mahler in 29:1). What’s new is the format; these DVDs are part of a new EuroArts series with the overall title Discovering Masterpieces of Classical Music. The performances are accompanied by a documentary that places the work within its composer’s life and the larger historical context. The video is in a widescreen (16:9) aspect, and the audio is available in PCM stereo, Dolby, and DTS 5.1 surround. English, German, French, and Spanish subtitles are provided for each documentary.

The documentaries are the standard combination of narration, commentary from contemporary sources, and lecture. In the case of the Beethoven, the work is examined movement by movement with explication provided by Wulf Konold and the musical examples illustrated by Abbado’s performance (Konold’s German is subtitled for non-German speakers). The explication should be comprehensible to anyone with a modicum of musical knowledge; excerpts from the printed score are used sparingly but usefully. I noticed one interesting anomaly: Konold explains that instead of repeating the Scherzo, fanfare and all, Beethoven provides the innovative transitional passage that leads to the finale. However, Abbado’s performance includes the optional full repeat of Scherzo and Trio.

The Mahler documentary follows the same template. Jeremy Barham provides somewhat redundant examples from the piano, since the excerpts from Abbado’s performance cover the same passages (though the piano examples illuminate the principal themes and may be easier for beginners to follow). Some of the narration is almost inaudible, though, vying as it does with the orchestra in full cry—an unfortunate weakness in this production.

For those of us raised on Bernstein’s Young People’s Concert broadcasts, these documentaries will seem dry, offering a few insights but few revelations and little of the personality of the incomparable Lenny. I also prefer the more insightful and colorful Keeping Score series from MTT and the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra. As volumes for a basic library of great music, though, these DVDs are more than adequate, mostly due to the superb performances by Abbado.

John Sheppard
MusicWeb International, November 2010

The cover of the box announces boldly that this DVD is “Introducing Beethoven Symphony No 5”. I would imagine that readers of this site are likely to have been introduced already, and may indeed feel that they are so familiar with the work, and possibly also the performers, that they would gain little from this DVD. That may be so, but I suspect that the proportion of the wider population who can claim to know more than the initial motto of the work is depressingly low today, and anything that is likely to increase the number who really know it is very much to be encouraged.

The documentary with which the disc opens begins with some historical information about the work. Excerpts from the Symphony play in the background, and sometimes with the performers also visible, below the speech. This is irritating as it is likely to encourage just the sort of casual background listening that the disc as a whole should discourage. The best parts of the documentary are the explanations by Wulf Konold. Sitting at a piano and speaking in German (with English subtitles) this is yet another vindication of the simple power of the “talking head” approach. He simply explains briefly and elegantly the structure and originality of the Symphony, occasionally throwing out remarks that resonate in the mind afterwards and do give a deeper understanding of the work. Extracts from the performance are included with relevant parts of the score shown on the screen. Perhaps it would be better for those with limited score-reading knowledge to have the old pantomime-style ball running along the notes, and, better still, for longer extracts to be included with the score visible. From time to time other voices, including a narrator, are used, mainly for biographical information. This is less interesting and not always relevant but does not greatly reduce the likely overall effectiveness of the documentary for anyone unfamiliar or with limited familiarity with the Symphony.

The performance follows, and I am tempted to think that the disc might be worth having for that alone. Abbado’s long experience with the work is shown not merely by the lack of a score or the almost instinctively elegant and eloquent way in which he deals with various passages notoriously difficult to conduct—Norman Del Mar’s book on conducting the Beethoven Symphonies explains this at length, but by the way in which he clarifies the textures and structure of the work. There is never any doubt that this is music whose relatively brief length gives no clue to its impact or importance. The performance is direct and powerful. The orchestra, looking at times alarmingly young, give of their best and the sound is never less than satisfactory even if some of the woodwind do display irritating mannerisms while playing. I could have done with more restraint in cutting of views around the orchestra, often for no obvious musical reason, but I have seen much worse. Even if the documentary may not work for the newcomer in introducing the greatness of the work then this performance certainly will.

Famous Composers Quick Link:
Bach | Beethoven | Chopin | Dowland | Handel | Haydn | Mozart | Glazunov | Schumann | R Strauss | Vivaldi
12:57:15 AM, 9 October 2015
All Naxos Historical, Naxos Classical Archives, Naxos Jazz, Folk and Rock Legends and Naxos Nostalgia titles are not available in the United States and some titles may not be available in Australia and Singapore because these countries have copyright laws that provide or may provide for terms of protection for sound recordings that differ from the rest of the world.
Copyright © 2015 Naxos Digital Services Ltd. All rights reserved.     Terms of Use     Privacy Policy
Classical Music Home
NOTICE: This site was unavailable for several hours on Saturday, June 25th 2011 due to some unexpected but essential maintenance work. We apologize for any inconvenience.