Classical Music Home

The World's Leading Classical Music Group

Email Password  
Not a subscriber yet?
Keyword Search
in
 
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews



 
See latest reviews of other albums...

Carla Rees
MusicWeb International, January 2008

Jean-Marie Leclair is probably best known as a prominent figure in the French style of violin playing. He developed standard violin technique through the use of an early form of vibrato, double trills and catalogued articulations. The majority of his compositional output was for the violin, but eight of his 48 violin sonatas were written with performance on the flute as an alternate.

The music, as played here, is fresh and imaginative, with the pre-requisite grandeur as necessary, contrasting the frivolous and technical fast movements and expressive adagios. Fenwick Smith plays with a wonderful sense of clarity and interpretative style; the music is played as though he truly loves it, and that comes across in the warm tone and emotive timbre of his sound. Formerly a member of the Boston Symphony Orchestra, Smith is a true master of the flute; this recording contains some of the finest playing I have heard. The other ensemble members accompany with panache, never dominating but always expressive and stylish.

Sometimes, the simplest of lines betray the true nature of the musicians who perform them. This can certainly be said of the Gavotte of the C major Sonata [CD 1, track 3]. I was completely transfixed by the colour and shape of the line. Other highlights for me include the flawless technical control over the leaping variations of the finale of the E minor sonata [CD 1, track 8]

Also notable on this disc is the inclusion of the Deuxième Récréation de Musique d’une Execution Facile [CD 2]. Here, Smith is ably joined by fellow flute player Christopher Krueger. The blend between the two players is remarkable and the ensemble is excellent. Here, also the continuo comes into its own with fugal lines with the solo parts above. I particularly enjoyed the lilting style of the Forlane [tr. 17] and the brief but charming Badinage [tr. 20].

Leclair is one of many baroque composers to write for the flute, at a time when the instrument was said to have had its ‘golden age’. His sonatas have a sparkle which sets them apart from his contemporaries; while it lacks the seriousness and emotional depth of Bach, there is a definite and pervasive sense of personality throughout. An image of him on the CD sleeve shows a smiling man with captivating eyes; his music seems to match this image. There is contrast between the works too; I initially suspected that a double CD of works for the same instrument by the same composer would prove too much to listen to in one sitting, but I was wrong. Much of the material here is captivating on the first hearing and becomes all the more enthralling with familiarity. This is partly due to the quality of the performance, but also the range of emotion and style encapsulated within the four movements of each sonata.

Everything about this recording is of an extremely high standard. It is a testament to Naxos that playing of this quality is available at such a reasonable price. Unmissable.



Brian Wilson
MusicWeb International, October 2007

"Full marks to Naxos for what they do so often and so well – spotting a gap in the market and filling it. Leclair did the same thing himself when he published his Op.1, Op.2 and Op.9 Violin Sonatas by identifying eight works in which the violin could be played on the flûte allemande or transverse flute. Only the end of Op.1/2 is too low for the flute: the solution employed here, for the flute to stop and allow the continuo to complete the final cadence of the Gigue, sounds perfectly acceptable. Flute fanciers and musicologists will want these CDs."



Brian Wilson
MusicWeb International, October 2007

"Full marks to Naxos for what they do so often and so well – spotting a gap in the market and filling it. Leclair did the same thing himself when he published his Op.1, Op.2 and Op.9 Violin Sonatas by identifying eight works in which the violin could be played on the flûte allemande or transverse flute. Only the end of Op.1/2 is too low for the flute: the solution employed here, for the flute to stop and allow the continuo to complete the final cadence of the Gigue, sounds perfectly acceptable. Flute fanciers and musicologists will want these CDs."



David Denton
David's Review Corner, September 2007

Born in Lyon in 1697 we first find Jean-Marie Leclair as a dancer at the Lyon Opera, and little is known of his musical training that changed him to a violinist and composer of the highest quality and esteem. He did give five years in the service to the royal court in the Netherlands, but otherwise spent the last forty years of his life in Paris where he was murdered in 1764. He wrote extensively for the violin including forty-eight sonatas, flautists grabbing the title page on eight of them which states ‘Cette Sonate peut se jouer sur la flute Allemande’, though they could simply have been a version of a violin sonatas aimed at extending sales to include the flute, as one of the sonatas goes outside the range of the flute at that time. The former principal flute of the Boston Symphony, Fenwick Smith, revels in the decorations of the fast outer movements, while producing an elegant silvery tone for the slow movements. I know he perform on the Baroque flute, but here I think he is playing a modern flute as the sound is not earthy enough for that period instrument. His intonation throughout is spotlessly clean, a comment that also passes over to the cello of Laura Blustein. Certainly Leclair intended the Trio Sonata for flute, the score giving more prominence to the harpsichord than in the sonatas where it just chugs along in the background. The two discs close with Leclair’s opus 8 for flute duet, harpsichord and cello, the overture and dance movements of joyous nature surrounding a Chaconne of considerable beauty. While in this era I concede that accompaniments were functional, I would have wished that Smith had been given less prominence in the sonatas, the sound otherwise well engineered.






Famous Composers Quick Link:
Bach | Beethoven | Chopin | Dowland | Handel | Haydn | Mozart | Glazunov | Schumann | R Strauss | Vivaldi
10:28:56 PM, 22 August 2014
All Naxos Historical, Naxos Classical Archives, Naxos Jazz, Folk and Rock Legends and Naxos Nostalgia titles are not available in the United States and some titles may not be available in Australia and Singapore because these countries have copyright laws that provide or may provide for terms of protection for sound recordings that differ from the rest of the world.
Copyright © 2014 Naxos Digital Services Ltd. All rights reserved.     Terms of Use     Privacy Policy
-212-
Classical Music Home
NOTICE: This site was unavailable for several hours on Saturday, June 25th 2011 due to some unexpected but essential maintenance work. We apologize for any inconvenience.