About this Recording
8.553195 - BERLIOZ: Romeo et Juliette / Les Troyens a Carthage

BERLIOZ (1803 - 1869)

Romeo and Juliet
The Trojans at Carthage: Prelude & Royal Hunt and Storm

At his best, Berlioz illuminated virtually every element of the Romantic Century: its national pulse and revolutionary ardour; the power of literature and its transformation in music and program; industry , invention, new instruments and sounds of every sort; vivid colour and bold harmonic design tinged with melancholy; and, above all, a sense of the obligations of Genius.

In his opera Les Troyens and symphonic poem Roméo et Juliette, Berlioz demonstrates an astonishing mastery of episode, expression, and impulse. Each is a dramatic realisation of a familiar tale, drawn from Berlioz' powerful grasp of the meta-human personalities within, and each is coloured by the hand of one of the great innovators of orchestration.

Across his career, in overture, song, symphony, and opera, Berlioz was inspired by literary themes and models. Although impelled by Shakespeare, his Romeo and Juliet was in fact made possible by the violinist Nicolà Paganini.

Recounts Berlioz in his Memoirs: "I hit upon the idea of a symphony with choruses, vocal solos, and choral recitatives on the sublime and ever-novel theme of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet. I wrote in prose all the text intended for the vocal pieces which come between the instrumental sections. Emile Deschamps, with his usual delightful good nature and marvellous facility, set it to verse... Paganini had given me money that I might write music, and write it I did."

It was composed from 20th January to 8th September, 1839, and given three try-outs at the Paris Conservatoire, these on 24th November, 1st and 15th December. Romeo and Juliet at first met bad reviews. One critic described it as "an ill-greased syringe." Berlioz in turn praised the critic as a "toad, swollen with imbecility." Even so, the composer privately acknowledged that "I should have to improve it a great deal." After performances in Berlin, Vienna, and Prague, numerous revisions were made.

It is a difficult score and Berlioz as a conductor recognised this from the first: "To interpret it properly, the artists - conductor, singers, and orchestra - must all be first-rate, and prepared to study it as a new opera is studied in good lyrical theatres... very nearly as though it were to be played by heart. It will, therefore, never be played in London, where the necessary rehearsals are not to be had. In that country, musicians have no time to make music."

Described variously as a choral symphony, symphonic poem, and 'symphonie dramatique', Romeo and Juliet is in seven parts: Introduction; Capulet's House; Balcony Scene; Queen Mab; Funeral Procession; Tomb Scene; and, Finale. Remarkably, the four 'traditional' movements of the nineteenth century symphony are embedded in its Andante malincolico -Allegro, Adagio, Scherzo prestissimo and Allegro agitato sections. In the remaining first, fifth, and seventh movements Berlioz employs solo voices (alto, tenor and bass) and six- part chorus.

Shakespeare's story concerns the Capulets and Montagues, two rival households in fourteenth century Verona. Its romance is that of Juliet for the son of her family's enemy. Forbidden to love openly, the teenagers are married in secret by their confessor, Friar Laurence. Drawn into a street quarrel, Romeo ultimately kills Juliet's cousin Tybalt. Banished from Verona, Romeo arranges a final night with Juliet and thereafter leaves the city. Friar Laurencecontrives with Juliet her feigned death and an ultimate reconciliation between Montague and Capulet. Unaware, Romeo returns to find her motionless in the family tomb. Tragedy follows a ghastly error in presuming her dead, his suicide by poison, and hers by dagger upon awakening to Romeo's dying embrace.

Berlioz' Romeo and Juliet owes its dramatic structure as much to English actor David Garrick (1717-1779) as to Shakespeare. The tomb scene, funeral march, and double chorus oath of reconciliation were adopted from the stage tradition of Garrick, who in turn simply made them up. They appear nowhere in the Folio.

For this recording, Yoav Talmi has chosen six excerpts. The orchestra makes an Introduction, violas naming the dark frantic energy of the town, weighted by grim descending low brass. The chorus enters in Prologue, ending a family celebration and foretelling catastrophe. Berlioz conjures the adolescent charm and over-reacting anguish of Romeo's soul, most naïvely in the solo oboe. The Scène d'amour follows, and here the chorus briefly quotes popular tunes heard at the Capulet celebrations.

Through the fantastic dance and sarcasm of La reine Mab we hear Berlioz' voice at its strongest. Queen Mab descended from Celtic myth. 'Medb' to the Irish and 'Maben' to the Welsh, this character was a deliverer of dreams, equally adroit in mischief and reverie, midwife to the faeries. How does Berlioz' Queen Mab enchant the dreamer? Listen to her rapid mood swings and irregular rhythms, the darting voices, the sudden episodes of alarm and energy. Woodwinds and strings serve Mab's rough humour. Orchestral texture remains light until a strange call in the English horn, luring the dreamer headlong into Mab's empire of insensibility. Rapid fugal replies in the strings change the mood again, and the surprising cry of a French horn alters the spell once more. Timpani and bass drum rumble and, after an unprepared loud climax, the mood veers into a clearing of violas and a brief allusion to its only rival in this strange field, Mendelssohn's Overture to A Midsummer Night's Dream. After an odd, stumbling hesitation, the last of Mab's jokes is told: her spell ends with a harmonic progression which, after all, plays by the rules of the waking world.

In his last and most moving scene, Roméo au tombeau, Berlioz adds to the pain of Romeo our pain in witness of his terrible misjudgment. From a desperate searching in the strings to the choral harmonies of horns and woodwinds in procession, in a return of Romeo's solitary oboe and the lonely waltz which follows, and finally in muted colour and Juliet's own call in the solo clarinet, this work is an astounding feat of musical incarnation.

So too, in very different ways, is his opera Les Troyens. Berlioz in February of 1853 visited Liszt at Weimar, renewing personal and artistic friendship. (Each composer dedicated his Faust to the other.) He discussed an opera on Shakespearean models using the text of Virgil's Aeneid. "For the last three years I have been tormented by the idea of writing a vast opera, of which I should write both words and music... I am resisting the temptation, and trust I shall continue to resist it to the end." Four years later, The Trojans was completed and ready for production.

And what a production it was. Berlioz' memoirs are riddled with contempt for the bureaucrats who demanded cuts, rewrites, and simply risible alterations. In a letter to the Emperor dated 28th March, 1858, Berlioz begged protection from two conductors "who are my enemies".

It was finally produced at the Théâtre-Lyrique in Paris on 4th November, 1863. "The performance was a flawed one, as it could hardly fail to be... it was absurd in some parts and ridiculous in others," wrote Berlioz. Its enormous length, huge orchestra and corps de ballet, tremendous staging and scenery requirements, and chaos among the producers led to fiasco. After opening night, ten more cuts were made.

'Declaring the opera's execution "a contemptible parody", Berlioz hectored at comic length: "Instead of a real waterfall, there was a painted one; the dancing satyrs were represented by little girls of twelve, and the blazing branches which they ought to have waved were forbidden for fear of fire. There were no dishevelled nymphs flying through the forest crying 'Italy!'..." and so on. It ran twenty-one nights.

In its five acts, the siege of Troy by the Greeks is evoked, a timely wooden horse appears, the fabled city is captured and burned, the Trojan women commit mass suicide. Seven years later, the surviving Trojans have fled to Carthage in North Africa and established a new kingdom. Dido and Aeneas meet in a cave, fauns dance, the gods intervene, Aeneas sails to Italy to become progenitor of the Roman people, and Dido ends her life. Hannibal is foretold, and a vision of the Roman capitol appears. The Fates have not chosen Carthage.

Despite its lamentable production history , the music endures. In this recording two excerpts appear. The Trojans at Carthage in its gold and silver, its brass and majesty, suggests the cityscape and heroic culture of this legendary place. The famous Royal Hunt and Storm is pure Berlioz: bursting, lyric, imperfect, and completely convincing.

Program Notes by
Charles Barber, © 1995.

San Diego Master Chorale
The San Diego Master Chorale is made up of 130 of San Diego's finest singers. It is the principal choral arts organization in the San Diego area. Founded in 1961 as the San Diego Symphony Chorale, the group became the San Diego Master Chorale in 1979 and bas since presented its own concert season while maintaining a rich collaboration with the San Diego Symphony Orchestra. Frank Almond, Music Director for the San Diego Master Chorale for ten years is also Professor of Music and Director of Choral Activities at San Diego State University, where he has taught for 24 years.

San Diego Symphony Orchestra
The San Diego Symphony Orchestra, now in its 67th season, is the oldest performing arts organization of America's sixth largest city, offering a year- round schedule of serious and popular concerts, as well as innovative outreach and audience development programmes. With a complement of 81 players the orchestra bas its winter season in Copley Symphony Hall, an opulent building that was once a cinema but is now owned by the San Diego Symphony Association. Winter season concerts also include silent films with orchestral accompaniment, a series of concerts for young people and multi-cultural concerts, representing the cultural diversity of the city. Summer brings an outdoor Pops season. Under its music director Yoav Talmi the San Diego Symphony Orchestra is recording for Naxos the complete orchestral works of Hector Berlioz and is the first American orchestra to record for the company.

Yoav Talmi
Yoav Talmi made his first appearance with the San Diego Symphony Orchestra in December 1987 and in 1990 began his tenure as Music Director, while continuing an active career with a series of international engagements. He has conducted major orchestras throughout Europe and North America, including the Berlin Philharmonic, all the leading London orchestras and the Amsterdam Concertgebouw. A graduate of the Tel-Aviv Rubin Academy of Music and the Juilliard School in New York, Yoav Talmi had his earlier experience as artistic director and conductor of the Gelders Orchestra in Arnhem from 1974 to 1980 and from 1979 to 1980 as principal guest conductor of the Munich Philharmonic. From 1984 to 1988 he was music director of the Israel Chamber Orchestra and from 1985 to 1989 of the New Israeli Opera. His awards include the Koussevitzky Conducting Prize in Tanglewood in 1969 and first prize in the Rupert Conductor's Competition in London in 1973. He has made numerous recordings, including solo albums with his wife, the distinguished flautist Er'ella Talmi.

Close the window