About this Recording
8.553396 - GRIEG, E.: Piano Music, Vol. 10 (Steen-Nøkleberg) - Lyric Pieces, Books 8-10

Edvard Grieg (1843 -1907)
Piano Music, Vol. 10
Lyric Pieces, Book 8, Op. 65 (1896)
Lyric Pieces, Book 9, Op. 68 (1899)
Lyric Pieces, Book 10, Op. 71 (1901)


Edvard Grieg was born in Bergen, on the west coast of Norway, in 1843. He showed a strong interest in music at a very early age, and after encouragement from the violinist and composer Ole Bull (1810-1880) was sent to the Conservatory in Leipzig at the age of fifteen to receive his musical education. There he had fundamental and solid musical training, and through the city's flourishing musical life, received impressions and heard music which would come to leave its stamp on him for the rest of his life - for better or for worse. Even though he severely criticized the Leipzig Conservatory, especially towards the end of his life, in reality his exceptional gifts were recognised, and one sees in his sketchbooks of the Leipzig period that he had the freedom to experiment as well. He had no good reason to criticize the conservatory, nor his teachers, for poor teaching or a lack of understanding.

From Leipzig Grieg travelled to Copenhagen, bringing with him the solid musical training he had acquired, and there soon became known as a promising young composer. It was not long before he came under the influence of Rikard Nordraak, whose glowing enthusiasm and unshakeable belief that the key to a successful future for Norwegian music lay in nationalism, in the uniquely Norwegian, the music of the people - folk-songs - came to play a decisive role in Grieg's development as a composer. Nordraak's influence is most obvious in the Humoresques for piano, Op. 6, which was considered a turning-point in Grieg's career as a composer.

In the autumn of 1866, Grieg settled in Christiania (Oslo). In 1874, Norway's capital was the centre for his activities. During this time he also wrote the majority of the works which laid the foundation for his steadily increasing fame. In spite of his poor health - he had had a defective lung ever since childhood - he was constantly on concert-tour as a pianist or as a conductor, always with his own works on the programme. After his last concert-tour in 1907, he wrote to his friend Frants Beyer:

This Tour has been strange. The Audiences have been on my Side. In Germany I have received more acclaim for my ART than ever before. But the Critics both in Munich and in Berlin have let me know in no uncertain terms, that they think I am a dead Man. That is my punishment for my lack of Productivity in these last Years, which my wretched physical condition has caused. It is a hard and undeserved Punishment - but I comfort myself with the thought that it is not the Critics, who govern the world. (Letter to Frants Beyer, 5 March 1907)

More clearly than anything else, this letter shows a trend which Grieg experienced in his later years in relation to his music. It was also a development which would continue internationally until long after his death. Within the musical "establishment", there were increasing numbers of people who were gradually becoming more critical of Grieg's music and of his abilities and talent as a composer. In the meantime his popularity among music-loving audiences increased in inverse proportion. Grieg enjoyed some of his greatest popularity with the general public during the last years of his life, when, in spite of his greatly weakened health, he was continually on tour, in popular demand from concert-managers all over the world. The critics, however, were sceptical and condescending, and there is no doubt that Grieg felt hurt by their attitude:

I cannot be blamed if my music is played in third-rate hotels and by school-girls. I could not have created my music any other way, even though I did not have my audience in mind at the time. I guess this popularity is all right, hut it is dearly bought. My reputation as a composer is suffering because of it, and the criticism is disparaging.' (Letter to Julius Röntgen, London, 25 May 1906)

From early on Grieg was labelled a composer of small forms. His indisputable lyrical ability and talent were never doubted, but apart from some very few works such as the Piano Concerto in A minor, Op. 16, and the String Quartet in G minor, Op. 27, the Piano Sonata in E minor, Op. 7, the three Violin Sonatas - Op. 8 in F major, Op. 13 in G major and Op. 45 in C minor - and the Cello Sonata in A minor, Op. 36, he was not able, in spite of his many desperate attempts to do so, to feel completely at home with more extended musical forms. He felt that this was a short-coming, and unfairly blamed his education at the Leipzig Conservatory. Nevertheless, he also showed that he could master these forms when on rare occasions he found raw musical material that could be reworked and treated within the traditional structure of sonata-form. The only problem was that the musical material to which he felt closest and that most fascinated him, was of another quality and character.

Grieg's encounter with Norwegian folk-music, and his assimilation of essential features from this music, released certain aspects of his own creativity that soon led to his music being, for many, identified with folk-music. By some he was considered more or less simply an arranger of folk-music, and that hurt him very deeply:

In my Op. 17 and Op. 66, I have arranged folk-songs for the piano, in Op. 30, I have freely rendered folk-ballads for the male voice. In three or four of my remaining works, I have attempted to use Norwegian songs thematically. And since I have published up to seventy works by now, I should be allowed to say that nothing is more incorrect than the claim from German critics that my so-called originality is limited to my borrowing from folk-music. It is quite another thing if a nationalistic spirit, which has been expressed through folk-music since ancient times, hovers over my original creative works.' (Letter to Henry T. Finck, 17 July 1900)

Much instrumental Norwegian folk-music is built from small melodic themes, units which are repeated with small variations in appoggiaturas and sometimes with rhythmic displacements. Sections are then joined together to form larger units. We seldom find any true development as it is understood in traditional classical music. It gradually became clear to Grieg that he felt the greatest affinity with this music. That is why it also became so difficult to distinguish between what in Grieg's works came originally from folk-music, and what was his own composition. This must also have been especially difficult for foreign critics and audiences.

In Grieg's music there are two features which particularly attract our attention, rhythm and harmony. In many instances Grieg's rhythm in his piano compositions is taken from the folk-dance, as well as from compositions which are not based upon folk-music. He placed great emphasis on the rhythmic element, and considered it paramount in the presentation of his works which have dance as the point of departure. He was of the opinion that in order to be able to play one of his compositions, one had to know and feel the dance rhythm. Characteristic of his understanding of the rhythmic element is the story about the meeting between Grieg and Ravel in Paris, in 1894, at the home of William Molard:

While the bright-eyed company discussed music, Ravel quietly went over to Molard's piano and began to play one of the master's Norwegian Dances. Grieg listened with a smile, but then began to show signs of impatience, suddenly getting up and saying sharply: "No, young man, not like that at all. Much more rhythm. It's a folk-dance, a peasant dance. You should see the peasants at home, with a fiddler stamping in time with music. Play it again!" And while Ravel played, the little man jumped up and skipped about the room to the astonishment of the company. (A Ravel Reader: Correspondence, articles, interviews, ed. Arbie Orenstein. New York: Columbia University Press, 1990, p. 237. This story comes from Lionel Carey, Delius: The Paris Years, p. 56.)

Harmony is at the heart of his work. Often it is the harmony itself which is the basis of the composition. Grieg pointed this out emphatically in a letter to his biographer, Henry T. Finck:

The realm of harmony, has always been my dream world, and my relationship to this harmonious way of feeling and the Norwegian Folk-songs has been a mystery even for me. I have understood that the secret depth one finds in our Folk-songs is basically owing to the richness of their untold harmonic possibilities. In my reworking of the folk-songs Op. 66, but also elsewhere, l have attempted to express my interpretation of the hidden harmonies in our folk-songs. (Letter to Henry T. Finck, 17 July 1900)

Grieg's interest in harmony had become obvious to others already while he was at the Conservatory. At that time it was first and foremost a desire to experiment. Later harmony became his way of bringing forth the very "soul" of the folk-tunes. Among other things, he deliberately used unfamiliar, "radical" chord progressions in order to suggest the vague tonality (sotto voce half tones, vague thirds) such as one finds in many of the songs, a melodic characteristic which would otherwise be impossible from an instrument like the piano.

Grieg's instrument was primarily the piano. From his earliest years to the concert-tour in the year he died, he performed as a pianist his own compositions. He was not a virtuoso, but his intimate familiarity with the piano allowed him to present his own music in such a way as to leave a deep and lasting impression upon everyone who heard him play. According to contemporary reports he had a marvellous ability to bring out the best, the very essence, of his own piano pieces. When he took his place on the platform, the atmosphere became electric, and the critics emphasized his refined touch, tone quality, and the complete absence of superficial gestures.

Grieg's music contributed very modestly to the development of piano technique. Most of his piano pieces are technically speaking within the abilities of competent amateurs. This, together with musical characteristics which seem to have a stimulating and refreshing effect, contributed to the fact that he was one of the most played, and respected composers in Europe-popular, if not with the critics, then at least with the majority of those interested in music.

Grieg's compositions were written in the epoch of the piano. Music and piano-playing in the average home were at a peak during the last half of the nineteenth century and the first decades of this century. Cyril Ehrlich has calculated that in 1910 alone more than 600,000 pianos were produced. To know how to play the piano was part of the general education in most middle-class families, especially for girls. No wonder the music publishers C. F. Peters hoisted the flag in London and Frankfurt every time Grieg delivered a manuscript for a new album of piano pieces. It is also understandable that Grieg sometimes experienced the demand for new piano pieces as a strain. There were also times when he felt that the production of piano pieces was a sort of bribe, or indulgence, to make sure that the publishing-house issued his other works as well. Nevertheless, in general, Grieg had an excellent relationship with his publisher in Leipzig. He was particularly close to Dr. Max Abraham (1831-1900), who became editor at Peters in 1863. This is dearly shown by the abundant correspondence that has been preserved. Verlagsbuchhandlung C. F. Peters Bureau de Musique, was the full name of the publishing-house that acted as Grieg's exclusive publisher from 1890 and agreed to pay him 4000 Marks every year, a sum which was adjusted to 6000 Marks in 1901. In return, Grieg was to offer Peters all of his future compositions with rights, für allen Länder (for all countries), for a certain fee.

Grieg experienced a great deal of adversity during certain periods of his life, but he also had more success than most other composer colleagues of his time. Nevertheless he never lost the feelings of unrest, of not having developed his talent to the full degree, of having left something undone, something unfulfilled within himself. Throughout his life, Grieg was a restless soul. He never felt completely at peace anywhere. When he was in Bergen, he longed for Christiania, and when he was there he longed for Copenhagen and the continent. When he was abroad, he longed to be back home, but no sooner had he arrived in Bergen than he felt oppressed and restless and wanted to go off again. There were perhaps only two places where he really felt at home and satisfied, on the concert-platform and in the Norwegian mountains, especially Jotunheimen. When he was in the presence of his audience or experiencing the powerful and free nature of the western part of Norway, he felt whole and complete.


Among Grieg's works, the Lyric Pieces seem to have a special place with a special significance in their order. That he apparently viewed them in the same way is clear from the fact that his last lyrical piece, 'Remembrances', Op. 71, No. 7, in 1901, quotes his first piece, 'Arietta', Op. 12, No. 1, of 1867. Thus the circle is completed, marking the end of the period in which he was concerned with this type of piano piece, a type that the whole world loved, admired, and above all, played. Even though he revealed his deepest, most intimate feelings in many of the lyrical pieces, the music remains approachable and is often played. It would probably be hard to find the piano student who has not learned to love these lyrical pieces, in spite of their occasional difficulty, and does not feel that the struggle has been worth while, if the results are good. One should ignore the fact that they have at times been looked upon with disdain as inferior. In fact they have survived as music that is both living and vital, because they are so strongly rooted in the consciousness of the people.

The expression Lyric Pieces is actually Grieg's own invention, but does not describe a genre. Character-pieces for the piano, with or without descriptive titles, have a long tradition and Grieg is only one to contribute to this, although his contribution is a very important one. Each of his lyric pieces, like Mendelssohn's Lieder ohne Worte, expresses only one mood, one feeling. From the publication of the second book, in 1883, (the first one came out in 1867), Grieg went on to publish collections of Lyric Pieces at regular intervals until 1901. They cover the greater part of Grieg's life as an established composer, and represent more or less every single facet of his personal style.

No attempt has been made to hide the fact that the lyric pieces gradually became good business, both for Grieg himself, as well as for the publishers. In a letter to Peters, Grieg called them Semmeln - fragrant, fresh-baked, bread - and the fact of the matter is that they were indeed sold like "hot cakes". No wonder the publisher Peters, in London and Frankfurt, was delighted every time Grieg delivered a manuscript for a new album of piano pieces. He was strongly attached to many of these pieces and enjoyed playing them, while there were others that he was not pleased with at all. In a letter to his friend, Emil Horneman, he writes:

My Silence is unforgivable, because I honestIy haven't done anything, other than the so-called, "Lyric Pieces", which are surrounding me like lice and fleas in the country. (Letter to Emil Horneman, 15 September 1898)

Other people also made snide remarks about them, such as Debussy's comment that the lyric pieces were like "pink candies filled with snow," probably alluding to the pink covers on the editions of the albums from Peters.

Grieg's Lyric Pieces contain 66 compositions, published in ten albums, during the years from 1867 to 1901. Most of these albums were printed again several times, and many of the pieces were published separately. Several of the most popular of them were published in innumerable arrangements, some by Grieg himself, but mostly by others.


From the last two albums we see that a certain kind of weariness crept into Grieg's life and work. He also mentions this himself. It was not a lessening of ability, as he so often feared might happen with age, because he knew that he still had the power to compose, but not always when the publisher or the public wanted him to do so. In Book 8, Op. 65, which was issued in 1897, just one year after the previous album, there are many examples that show that Grieg's inspiration had not abandoned him. High on the list is No. 6, 'Wedding-Day at Troldhaugen', a festive work which was originally a present for Nina Grieg, his wife, on their wedding-day, 11 June. Grieg wrote the same piece to commemorate the 50th birthday of a dear friend of theirs, Nancy Giertsen, and gave it the title, 'Bearers of Glad Tidings'. When proof-reading the first edition, however, he changed the title to the one we know it by today, 'Wedding-Day at Troldhaugen'. In the first piece of the eighth set, 'From Days of Youth', Grieg looks back with an element of despair and melancholy in his tone. The second, 'Peasant's Song', and the fifth, 'In Ballad Style', reminds us again of his unpretentious spontaneity as we know it from some of the compositions from the first of the Lyric Pieces. In the third, 'Melanchaly', and the fourth, 'Drawing-Room', it is the harmonic subtleties that are the most important element.

The next to last collection of Lyric Pieces, Book 9, Op. 68, was published in 1899. We again find a mixture of salon compositions, laced with harmonic subtleties, as in the third and sixth pieces, 'At Your Feet' and 'Melancholy Waltz', and pieces that have their roots in Norwegian landscape and in folk-music. 'Cradle-song', No. 5, belongs to this category, and both from a melodic as well as harmonic point of view, it could have been apart of Op. 66, the 19 Norwegian Folk-Songs. The most interesting piece in the album, however, is the fourth, 'Evening in the Mountains'. In the manuscript from 1898 Grieg has also used the titles: 'Cow-Call', and 'The Mountaineer's Song', and on a copy he gave to Marie and Frants Beyer, on their silver wedding anniversary in 1902, he wrote: "Imagine the Evening Atmosphere at Utladalen, (skogadals-boen), the mountain farm in Jotunheimen." Grieg also writes to Beyer:

Just thinking of the mountain-tops, I feel that I can breathe more easily, and I am filled with a greater love of life. (Letter to Frants Beyer, 15th February, 1899)

It was approximately at this time that Grieg rearranged 'Cradle-song', and 'Evening in the Mountains' for string orchestra, a version published in 1900, with the second piece scored also with oboe and French horn.

In 1901 Grieg brought to an end his series of Lyric Pieces with the publication of Book 10, Op. 71. It can be understood that he intended this to be definite and conclusive, because he includes in the last piece of the last book 'Memories', No. 7, a quotation from the first piece of the first collection, 'Arietta'. Now, however, it has been transformed into a vulnerable, melancholy waltz, of the type one might dance when the party is over, where, in spite of being a little intoxicated, one may try to maintain an image of propriety. In the end everything dies out in ppp. This is not the only piece which alludes to the past. In the fifth piece, 'Halling', a folk-dance, he uses the thematic material of 'Bridal Procession', Op. 19, No. 2, and this is one of the most technically demanding folk-dance inspired pieces he ever wrote. As in Opp. 57 and 65, he also opens this collection with a nostalgic piece which looks back to the earlier years, 'Once upon a time', and to make it clear that everything comes to an end, he takes yet another bitter-sweet, backward glance in 'Forbi' (Gone), as the collection's next to last piece. It has written over it, 'In Memoriam', a reminder of the past. At the same time he looks forward with a partly impressionistic and extremely sentimental 'Summer Eve', No. 2 and 'Peace of the Woods', No. 4. After much careful planning, he placed the goblin 'Puck', between them, a piece, which, with its lightness and vivacity, does not give the impression of old age, or that life that has passed one by.

The series was supposed to end with Op. 71, but in fact yet another book of piano pieces was published, which in character and content belongs to the Lyric Pieces. This is Moods, Op. 73. In this series it is recorded and discussed in another connection.


Øyvind Nordheim
English translation: Phyllis Nyquist

Close the window