About this Recording
8.571202 - COPLAND, A.: Rodeo / Piano Concerto / Billy the Kid Suite (Hollander, Seattle Symphony, Schwarz)

Aaron Copland (1900–1990)


Rodeo: Four Dance Episodes

Aaron Copland occupies an unassailable position in the music of the United States of America. The son of Jewish emigrants from Poland and Lithuania, he was born in Brooklyn in 1900, into circumstances comfortable enough to allow him the study of music. He took lessons from Goldmark, a distinguished emigrant from Vienna, and in 1920 went to Paris, where he studied with Nadia Boulanger, the first of her American pupils. In Europe he was able to meet a number of the leading young composers of the day and to see performances by Diaghilev’s Ballets Russes. At the same time he was feeling his way towards a characteristically American style of composition, that should be as clearly recognisable as the national style of the late nineteenth-century Russian composers.

In 1924 Copland returned to America, where his compositions began to attract interest. At the same time he continued to maintain contact with musical trends in Europe and with expatriate American composers. He organised important series of concerts of contemporary American music, which he did his utmost to publicise through his writing and lecturing, the second activity intermittently at Harvard. During the course of an exceptionally active career, he exercised a strong influence over a younger generation of composers, without in any way fostering an exclusive nationalism. His achievements won him awards of all kinds, at home and abroad, from the Pulitzer Prize in 1945 to the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany in 1970.

Rodeo was completed in 1942 and first staged in the same year by the Ballet Russe de Monte Carlo, with choreography by Agnes de Mille, niece of the Hollywood film producer and one of the most distinguished American ballerinas of the day. The subtitle of the ballet, The Courting at Burnt Ranch, describes accurately enough its slender plot. The cowboys chase every woman they see but pay little attention to the girl working with them on the ranch. The situation changes, however, when she appears at a Saturday night ball dressed for the occasion, and the famous ‘Hoe Down’ is danced, the first time a square-dance had intruded into the world of ballet. The four dance episodes that form the orchestral suite open with ‘Buckaroo Holiday’, followed by the tranquillity of ‘Corral Nocturne’. The mood changes with ‘Saturday Night Waltz’ and the final ‘Hoe Down’.

Keith Anderson

Piano Concerto

Copland’s Piano Concerto, like The Tender Land, a work not often heard, is ‘early Copland’: 1926. It comes two years after George Gershwin’s Rhapsody in Blue and a year following Gershwin’s Piano Concerto in F, works that created a great stir and controversy in the music world. Paul Rosenfeld, who championed Copland in the intellectual press, treated the Piano Concerto as a response to these Gershwin piano-and-orchestra vehicles (which he argued were compositionally inferior to Copland’s ‘improvement’). Copland himself never confirmed that Gershwin was a catalyst for his one composition for piano and orchestra. In fact, Copland rarely spoke or wrote about Gershwin. An exceptional occasion, when he did, was a question-and-answer at New York’s WPA Theatre of Music in 1937. Copland was asked to compare his music ‘with Mr Gershwin’s jazz’. His answer: ‘Gershwin is serious up to a point. My idea was to intensify it. Not what you get in the dance hall but to use it cubistically—to make it more exciting than ordinary jazz.’

In the Piano Concerto, arguably the ‘jazziest’ piece in Copland’s entire output, the evident jazz voice is wedded to a conscious compositional sophistication that Copland put into words when he commented that his aim was ‘to explore new avenues in the area of polyrhythms’ and ‘to experiment with shifting beats by introducing a variety of highly unorthodox and frequently changing rhythms that made the music polymetric’.

Copland’s Piano Concerto resulted from a commission from Sergey Koussevitzky and the Boston Symphony. ‘If you write a piano concerto’, Koussevitzky told him, ‘you can play it yourself.’ While we may not today remember Copland as a pianist—in his later performing career he was a conductor—his recording of the concerto with Leonard Bernstein, and even more his live performances captured on broadcast, reveal a bracing keyboard talent. In a note for the concerto Copland wrote of the soloist ‘improvising’, and the concerto’s second movement is headed molto rubato (inviting rhythmic license). While there is no actual improvisation in the keyboard part, Copland’s own performances of the work bristle with impressions of freedom and spontaneity, even to the point of wildness.

The two movements are linked. The first is bluesy. The second, once termed by the composer a ‘snappy number’, is introduced by a remarkably rambunctious piano solo. Near the close, preceding a wicked coda, there is an expansive reprise of the first movement’s blues song; here it is difficult not to be reminded of a similar reprise at the close of Gershwin’s concerto. And, again like that work, it is a 1920s ‘New York’ piece: brassy, exuberant, ever confident in its bluesy swagger.

The Boston reviews were unkind. ‘No music heard at these concerts in the past fifteen years has created so great a sensation,’ reported the Globe. ‘The audience forgot its manners, exchanging scathing verbal comments, and giggled nervously…creating so great a bustle that at times it was difficult to hear the music clearly.’ Focusing on the opening solo, ‘struck by fingers apparently directed at random, as a child amuses itself by making noises when it is restless in the room’, Philip Hale—an important Boston voice—amplified in the Herald: ‘the audience laughed, as if the Concerto were a huge joke played on the hearers, also on Mr Koussevitzky.’ A third critic wrote, ‘with no effort at all the listener visualizes a jazz dance hall next door to a poultry yard.’ Today, we no longer hear a barnyard when we hear Copland’s Piano Concerto. But it is worth being reminded how bold this music once sounded.

Joseph Horowitz

Billy the Kid: Suite

Copland composed his hugely popular one-act ballet Billy the Kid in Paris and Peterborough, New Hampshire, in the summer of 1938. Written for Lincoln Kirstein’s Ballet Caravan and with choreography by Eugene Loring and decor by Jared French, the work was first made in an arrangement for two pianos (the soloists were Arthur Gold and Walter Hendl) on 6 October 1938 in Chicago. The orchestral version was first performed in New York the following year and in 1940 the seven-movement orchestral suite from the ballet was given its first performance by the NBC Symphony Orchestra under William Steinberg, once again in New York.

The scenario centres upon the chief episodes in the short-lived career of the American outlaw William H. Bonney (1859–1881). The action, framed by depictions of the open prairie, starts in the street of a frontier town: during a drunken brawl guns are drawn and Billy’s mother is accidentally shot and killed. In a rage, Billy, then a boy of only twelve, draws a blade from a cowboy’s sheath and stabs his mother’s killers: so begins his life as an outlaw. Several scenes from his later life are depicted, including a night-time card game, a gun battle between Billy and his former associate Pat Garrett, and the celebrations that follow Billy’s capture. After his escape from prison and a pas de deux with his girlfriend in the desert, both omitted from the orchestral suite, Billy finally meets his demise.

Peter Quinn

Close the window