About this Recording
8.571260 - BEETHOVEN, L. van: Piano Sonatas, Vol. 5 (Biret) - Nos. 9, 10, 13, 14 (Biret Beethoven Edition, Vol. 10)

Ludwig van Beethoven (1770–1827)
Piano Sonatas, Volume 5
Sonata No. 9 in E major, Op. 14, No. 1
Sonata No. 10 in G major, Op. 14, No. 2
Sonata No. 13 in E flat major, Op. 27, No. 1 (Sonata quasi una fantasia)
Sonata No. 14 in C sharp minor, Op. 27, No. 2 (Sonata quasi una fantasia) (Moonlight)


Beethoven’s two Sonatas Op. 14, along with the Sonata for Horn and Piano of 1801, were dedicated to Baroness Josefine von Braun, wife of the Baron Peter, a successful businessman and lessee of the National-Theater, and afterwards of the Theater-an-der-Wien. Although this was an early association of the composer’s which eventually led to an invitation to write an opera, we do not really know whether he enjoyed a strong social footing with either husband or wife. Mollo was the name of the publishing house; the announcement date 21 December 1799.

Only of the Sonata No. 9 in E major, Op. 14, No. 1, do copious sketches appear in Nottebohm’s publication Zweite Beethoveniana that also includes the Sonata for Violin and Piano, Op. 12, No. 3, and the Piano Concerto in B flat. The composer adapted it as a string quartet, transposing it up one semitone to accommodate the cello part. Essentially a lyrical work, this gentle sonata at first appears a somewhat introspective work, rather unassuming in its easy-sounding fluency and harmless initial statement with repeat. Yet the second subject of the Allegro, with right-hand octaves over those favourite left-hand semiquaver groupings, raises the temperature while leading back to the main subject, played forte to rising scale accompaniment. Apart from various sforzandi emphases in sudden chord modulations, the ending is peaceful.

The Allegretto second movement with its three-note phrase (E minor) and unexpected G major reply insertion, has an almost foresighted Schubertian quality, particularly in the ‘decorated’ restatement, but the maggiore c major central part transforms pessimistic feelings into regal assertiveness. Beethoven’s added coda, following the repeat, is plaintively simple.

In contrast, the final Rondo is roguishly playful, the three-note quavers in the left hand providing a boisterous gait to right-hand octaves. The reply figure with downward spirals of sixteenth notes (semiquavers)—then in contrary motion—has the rustic flavour of Austrian peasants playing practical jokes on ignorant foreigners. Beethoven, of course, adds to everyone’s confusion by interchanging hands in the matter of quavers and octaves, and altering the key rapidly at the same time. A scale up the keyboard temporarily readjusts normality in the return of the main subject, then the music runs amock in successions of hammered octaves, sforzandi, suddenly switching to offhand charm at the close.

Schindler provides a visionary account of Beethoven’s playing where ‘the hearer could fancy he actually beheld the lover in his living form, and heard him apostrophizing his obdurate mistress’. There is a good deal of evident ‘persuasiveness’ in the offbeat six-note phrase that begins the Allegro of Sonata No. 10 in G major, Op. 14, No. 2. An insistent rocking motion pervades the whole movement, a feeling of song-like ardency in wide-spaced intervals of octaves and tenths stretching the hero’s attempts to serenade his sweetheart in a constant stream of legato melody that allows for no interruptions—one has the strong suspicion that this all occurs on the waters of a lake during a bright summer afternoon. At some point during the second G minor subject (overshadowed by E flat), things go slightly out of control and attempts to right matters become rather strenuous. Overall invention however, is at its peak.

The Andante (La prima parte senza replica), Alla breve and in C major, the ‘male’ rôle in mid register, the ‘female’ reply higher up, is a stilted, mock-serious conversation piece. Together, there is a descant quality to the writing, complete with holy intentions. Beethoven transforms his main theme into decorative semiquaver three-note groups and flourishes, reverting to a straightforward ending with a startling octave chord.

The Scherzo, marked Allegro assai, is a kind of ‘catch me, if you can’, with fleeting scampers up the scale, then tiny, playful quick retorts with both hands actively involved. Altogether, some of the most entrancing music penned, and pre-Rossini.

Beethoven designated both his Sonatas, Op. 27, with the subtitle Sonata quasi una fantasia. Thayer refers to this as “a departure from the customary structure”, while Denis Matthews, more cleverly, sees this as “disarming criticism of their unorthodox procedures”. Two occurrences in the years 1800–1, one actual and the other delayed, also surround the conception and completion of these and other works by the composer. In the 1790s Viennese pianos were almost entirely made of wood; only the strings and tuning pins were metal. Their range was five octaves, so that all of Haydn’s and Mozart’s compositions for pianoforte, as well as Beethoven’s up to his Third Concerto, were confined to the restricted compass. An advertisement in 1799 (not Viennese) offered an extension up to six octaves, while the firm of Streicher made certain refinements to J. Andreas Stein’s escapement. The new standard for pianos made in Vienna (‘bouncing’) with their shallow key-fall and small hammers covered with leather, became known as the “Vienna action”. The tone was light, and long, thin bass strings were used to compensate for any weaknesses in the lower registers. At the turn of the century Matthias Müller, the Vienna piano-maker, announced his new upright pianoforte, set up on its tail on the floor in a rectangular case. It would stand about 5 feet 2 inches, and instead of the gap in the sounding-board for the hammers to strike the strings from behind, he devised a down-striking action. Unfortunately he was years ahead of the times, and limited production costs made the price too high for sufficient people to become interested. The idea did not catch on finally until years later, following the designation of his model with the unpronounceable title Ditalleloclange. Beethoven, with his Hungarian court secretary friend, the musical amateur cellist Domanovecz, occupied his time instead trying out the good Streicher piano. This became incorporated into their Sunday afternoon chamber-music gatherings.

The dedication of Sonata No. 13 in E flat major, Op. 27, No. 1, is to Princess Liechtenstein, sometimes referred to as Josephine instead of the Princess Johanna. Despite a paucity of new works in 1800, Beethoven was involved with revisions and completions, and was working on his music to Prometheus as well as this new sonata. The gentle Andante, Alla breve which opens the first movement, strumming chords in the right hand, rising-falling semiquavers in the left, acts as a chain link to other ideas and subject matter. The contrasting chords in the answering subject, for instance, already give warning of the passionate Allegro C major episode which forms the central argument, where the metre changes to 6/8 for a continuous coursing of fierce arpeggios over forte accented chords. At first hearing, the key sequence appears to be foreign to the ears.

At the close of the ritornello, a high C major pianissimo chord provides the Attacca subito for the Allegro molto vivace movement that follows. The notation on manuscript appears simple and direct; the argument, however, is complex, with a winding motion of crotchets (both hands) travelling in alternate directions, interspersed with sudden crescendi to heighten the tension. A middle section (A flat) ascends rapidly in stark sounding staccato notes topped by a fortissimo G flat trill, then falls suddenly in offbeat pianissimo notes like rain pattering against a window pane.

The reprise is followed by a second attacca that ushers in the glorious Adagio con espressione in A flat major, a sorrowful golden-toned lament that ascends into higher regions, piercing the heart strings with hidden desires. One can try guessing the composer’s inner thoughts, but Beethoven ultimately abandons any studious contemplation with a magnificent cadenza flourish, demisemiquavers ascending to G-A flat above the stave progressing downwards to an octave below, for the final attacca and Allegro vivace Finale.

I see this whole movement as a game of chance. We have returned to the home key, but instead of the studied contentment of the first movement the picture is now one of gay abandon, almost a reversal of earlier material, newly placed in a decorative setting of E flat pitted against A flat—all highly motivated by varying the left-hand figuration to keep everything constantly on the move. Beethoven’s teasing wit interplays flats, sharps and naturals to lead the music into unknown paths and situations, enlarging the scope of brilliance by employing staccato octaves and szforzando trills. The final Presto, prefaced by a shorter cadenza, is quite hilarious.

The dedication of Sonata No. 14 in C sharp minor, Op. 27, No. 2, is to Countess Giulietta Guicciardi. The work appeared separately from its predecessor. The first of the three movements is probably the most nearly unique among Beethoven’s sonatas, although the hidden programme, suggested through the composer’s over-exaggerated relations with the Countess, has never been proven. We have it on authority from Jahn’s conversations with the lady in 1852 that Beethoven never had her in mind while composing the work. Dr Grosheim of Cassel even suggested that the Adagio movement would be ideal as a mood setting to Seume’s poem Die Beterin. While agreeing to the voice-piano arrangement, some time in the years 1816–17, Beethoven never complied.

This sonata contains none of the daring innovations of Op.27, No.1, the writing being regular in style, tight in its constructive skill but prophetic in utterance. The opening Adagio sostenuto e senza sordini, is wonderfully held together with sustained pianissimo octaves interlinking with triplet quavers in the right hand (first three bars, thereafter legato). When the sublime flowing melody appears (bar 5) one immediately senses the contained passions therein. There is a slight resemblance to the central movement of the “PathétiqueSonata, but here the overall mood is deeper, more significant. The pianist must make every note “sound” within an evenness of context.

The disarming simplicity of the Allegretto movement in D flat major, based on four-note replies and slightly varied second time round, is thrown into relief by the bolder emphasis of the Trio section. Astute listeners will spot the composer’s ‘disguised’ intentions to invert his melodic line in the first stanza, and, abbreviating his notation in the second, to lead back to the Allegretto repeat.

The Presto agitato returns us to the home key of the first movement. The whole onsurge of music is Beethoven at his most fiery and commanding. The rippling semiquaver figuration and growling, thundering left-hand quavers, along with punctuated sforzandi chords and demonic crescendi are frightening to the listener on first hearing. One notices the fingerprints that would make the finale of the “Appassionata” Sonata even more powerful; the tyrannical build-up to the A major chord, followed by patterns of semiquavers, the huge series of spread chords midway through the final apotheosis, the fleeting cadenza before the coda.

Rellstab applied the title Moonlight to the sonata after Beethoven’s death. There is no knowing what he might have thought of the suggestion.

Bill Newman

Close the window