About this Recording
8.573167 - DALE, B.: Viola Music (Complete) (The Romantic Viola) (Yuko Inoue, S. Coombs)

Benjamin James Dale (1885–1943): The Romantic Viola
Suite for Viola and Piano in D major, Op 2 • Introduction and Andante for Six Violas, Op 5 • Phantasy for Viola and Piano, Op 4


Edwin Evans wrote of Dale in The Musical Times on 1 May 1919: “‘He has written fewer and better works than any English composer of his generation.’ That is the considered opinion of a well-known English musician.”

Benjamin James Dale was born on 17 July 1885 in Crouch Hill, North London. His father, Charles James, was a self-taught amateur musician and successful businessman who both founded and became principal of the Metropolitan College of Music in Holloway. His brother Henry was awarded the Nobel Prize for Medicine in 1936 and was very supportive of Benjamin, who was ten years his junior. In September 1900, aged fifteen, Benjamin Dale entered the Royal Academy of Music, along with an old friend, the pianist and composer York Bowen, with whom he kept a close friendship for the rest of his life. Dale, Bowen and another of his contemporaries, Arnold Bax, all studied composition under the hugely influential Frederick Corder. At the same time, in 1900, the great virtuoso and father of the modern viola, Lionel Tertis, became professor of viola at the Royal Academy and took it upon himself to encourage colleagues and students such as Dale and Bowen to compose for an instrument that had almost no existing solo repertoire. Tertis’s influence is evident as, while still a student at the RAM, Dale wrote the Suite for Viola and Piano in D major, Op 2 for him, following the huge success of his first major composition, his Piano Sonata in D minor, Op 1, that was written for and first performed by the then famous concert pianist Bowen on 14 November 1905.

The opening two movements of the Suite, originally entitled Fantasy-Prelude and Romance respectively, were given their première by Tertis and Bowen on 30th October 1906. This was followed by a performance of the complete work in 1907. Tertis, who was particularly fond of the first two movements, asked Dale to orchestrate them. The orchestrated versions were subsequently performed at a Royal Philharmonic Society concert conducted by Arthur Nikisch on the 18 May 1911.

The piece opens with fanfare-like chords on the piano that give a strong feeling of youth, confidence and incredible happiness. The second movement, Romance, is elegant with glorious melodies, finishing with a forceful and majestic finale. In the original score, towards the end of the second movement, there is an extra bar of D flat major arpeggios in the piano part. We thought it appropriate to re-introduce this extra bar to give more space before the viola makes its entry into the final melody. The Suite is a monumental work; over thirty minutes of music that requires great virtuosity and high technical skill from both players.

In order to demonstrate how contemporary compositions were changing the world of the viola, Tertis decided to give a lecture-recital about the rise of the viola, for which he commissioned Dale to write a short piece for him and five students. The sextet, entitled Introduction and Andante for Six Violas, Op 5, had its première in 1911.

Dale’s teacher, Corder, wrote in his letter to The Musical Times in 1917:

a work of remarkable beauty, power and originality…the six instruments all have highly independent parts, they imitate the sounds of other instruments, they do things that one would have thought impossible for any viola-player, and the effect of the whole is of an almost Beethovenish majesty and grandeur and a melodic sweep such as none other of the present generation of string-writers seems able to approach”.

Dale promoted a number of techniques that were not often used in English chamber music at the time, such as pizzicato, tremolos, ponticello and harmonics in all six parts, also instructing the sixth viola’s C string to be tuned down to a G in order to reach the bass A flat in the last bar, considerably extending the maximum range that is normally possible on the viola.

In 1910 a retired businessman and amateur violinist, Walter Wilson Cobbett, decided to commission eleven young British composers to each write a Phantasy, his own unique spelling of the more common Fantasy. Dale was one of those challenged, and amongst others were Bowen, Bridge and Vaughan Williams. Dale’s resulting Phantasy in D minor-major for Viola and Piano, Op 4, is a single movement lasting over 20 minutes, even though the suggested length had been only 12 minutes! Originally entitled Ballade, it may well have already been written before Cobbett’s request. It was premièred on December 14, 1910 by Tertis and Bowen.

The piece has only one movement, but can be divided roughly into the following three sections:

I: Lento as an introduction and onto a light Allegro
II: Andante espressivo
III: A scherzo-like Allegro molto, a short Andante that leads back to Lento, and then Molto lento.

Studying the original manuscript in the Royal Academy library, I could see that Dale originally ended the piece with a flourish in D major. He changed his mind, however, and instead brought back the sublime opening tune, finishing the movement with the beautiful and heavenly melody shared between viola and piano, finally ending with the simple arpeggios in the piano under a long, high D sustained by the viola.

It was useful to have a chance to look at the original scores of all Dale’s viola music, and interesting to see some of his original intentions in his compositions. There are many instances, not only in the Phantasy but also in the Suite, where although he keeps a long, legato melody in the piano part, the viola part for a similar or even identical melody is broken up, with tenuto markings to separate the legato line. I personally feel that this may have been Tertis’s suggestion, in order to give the viola part a better chance of being heard alongside the beautiful but nevertheless somewhat thick piano writing. How willing Dale was to make such changes however remains unclear.

It is a tragedy that Dale did not compose more. In August 1914 at the outbreak of the First World War, Dale was unfortunate enough to be on holiday in Germany. He was interned at Ruhleben and did not return to England until 1918. A year after Dale’s return, Edwin Evans wrote that “his admirers were looking forward with much curiosity to the composition upon which he is now engaged”. Dale’s health was impaired, however, and though he wrote a Violin Sonata in 1922, the rest of his life was spent mainly working in education, primarily at the Royal Academy, with occasional tours to New Zealand and Australia to examine for the Associated Board. Ultimately, he failed to fulfil the earlier expectations of many, including his former teacher Frederick Corder. Dale died on 30 July 1943, just after his 58th birthday.

This recording was made following the success of a Viola Festival, The British Viola – Romantic and Contemporary, that I directed with the support of the Strings faculty at the Royal Academy of Music in London in 2011-12. The festival promoted the wonderfully romantic viola repertoire that was written in the first half of the twentieth century by, amongst others, Dale, Bowen and Rebecca Clarke, alongside new repertoire by living British composers. Unashamedly romantic in style, many of the pieces had been very successful at the time, but as the style of classical music changed following the World Wars, they became outdated and all but forgotten. I am particularly pleased that we were able to record these wonderful but under-appreciated pieces at the very institute in which they were written almost exactly a century ago.

My greatest gratitude goes to the Vaughan Williams Trust and The Royal Academy of Music for their generous contribution towards the making of this recording.

These notes were supplemented with information from the following sources:

The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians
Modern British Composer III, E. Evans, The Musical Times, 1 May 1919
A Reassessment of Benjamin Dale, Christopher Foreman

Yuko Inoue

Close the window