Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Email Password  
Not a subscriber yet?  
Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Penguin Guide, January 2009

One associates Koussevitzky with Debussy, Sibelius, Ravel and Prokofiev rather than with Wagner. These records, made between 1946 and 1949, show him as no less masterly and authoritative an interpreter of the Master of Bayreuth. Under him the Boston Symphony was peerless and these performances are in every respect a joy.

American Record Guide, August 2008

The cult of genius is much deprecated these days, at least the cult of individual genius. The shrines of nation, class, region, and race reek with incense. Koussevitzky is classed as Russian, Franco-Russian, American, and Bostonian, all of which he was, with the attendant characteristics. But how is it, hearing these thrice- familiar works, all given straightforward interpretations, that one recognizes a conductor as unique as his fingerprints?

The sound of the orchestra, for one thing: sleek, smooth, powerful, purring like a well­tuned 12-cylinder engine. There are all the little graces, the thunder-crack in the Dutchman, the transparency of sound in Parsifal, the dash and swagger of rhythm in the Academic Festival Overture—all done to perfection.

Perhaps the genius of Koussevitzky lay in knowing where to stop, giving full measure of spontaneity without tipping into vulgar display. Sprezzatura. A few others had this rare capacity: Beecham, Furtwangler, Toscanini—all instantly recognizable. A gift from the gods, surely. Nor is the resentment of genius difficult to understand, for performances like these render lesser things odious.

Rob Maynard
MusicWeb International, April 2008

Serge Koussevitzky was a victim of his dates. Born in 1874, he retired in 1949 after 25 years at the helm of the Boston Symphony Orchestra and died only two years later.

As such, he just missed out on the huge technological advances, including the widespread adoption of stereo recording and of the LP format, that would transform the recording industry in the 1950s. Thus the bulk of his recorded legacy fell, for many years, into something like oblivion as – to consider only his American peers - Ormandy, Szell, Bernstein and others began re-recording the core repertoire in high fidelity sound.

To be sure, Koussevitzky’s memory lived vividly on among those who had been present at his concerts, but that dwindling band was not enough to keep his name in the public eye for long.

Now, though, the fashion for disinterring and remastering old recordings is uncovering some long-neglected treasures (plus, as should only have been expected, a great deal of mundane material) and thereby giving a wider audience the opportunity to reappraise some of the frequently far larger than life characters who ruled the world’s orchestras in the first half of the twentieth century.

So what does this Naxos Historical release, excellently remastered by Mark Obert-Thorn, tell us about Serge Koussevitzky?

Let us first of all be clear what it does not tell us. There is no indication here of the reason why Koussevitzky deserves to be remembered even if he had made no recordings at all: the commissioning and performing of a very wide range of new music. As Colin Anderson’s useful booklet notes remind us, many of the most important composers working at the time – including Hindemith, Prokofiev, Stravinsky, Bartók, Britten, Barber, Copland, Harris, Piston and Schuman – were among the recipients of the Koussevitzky regime’s largesse.

This new release focuses instead on more conventional offerings that would, in the increasingly conservative late 1940s, have probably pleased most of the Symphony Hall audience rather more.

The bulk of what we have here is music by Wagner and I was particularly eager to listen to the disc after reading John L. Holmes’s assessment (Conductors: A record collector’s guide [Victor Gollancz, 1988]) that “Koussevitzky was less certain with Wagner, and recorded very little of the composer…”.

On the basis of these tracks it is difficult to see what Holmes’s throwaway aside is getting at. These are appealing, confident and highly musical accounts. As required, they are full of life and energy (the terrific opening of the overture to The Flying Dutchman will knock you out of your seat), majesty and spirituality (the Lohengrin and Parsifal extracts), lyricism (the Siegfried Idyll) and, when appropriate, touches of emphatic theatricality (let’s not forget that we have here extracts from three works written to be performed on an operatic stage).

The performances are also quite distinctive: the typical Koussevitzky sound is not aiming for homogeneity, let alone “beauty” for its own sake (although many passages are actually very beautiful indeed). On the contrary, here is a conductor positively revelling in opportunities for tonal contrast and for highlighting the individual strengths – and, inadvertently, some of the weaknesses - of the various sections of his orchestra.

The Brahms overture is a vigorous and thrusting account. Koussevitzky must have had a lot of spare time at the Moscow conservatory – he is said to have completed the five years course for double bass players in just five months! – and it sounds, from this account, that he certainly enjoyed student life himself.

If he had lived and worked for just a few more years (as, after all, Toscanini did) Koussevitzky might well enjoy an entirely different reputation today. As it is, this disc – once one comes to terms with the distinctly subfusc sound – is of immense interest in highlighting his distinctive characteristics as a musician and an under-appreciated conductor.

David Denton
David's Review Corner, March 2008

As part of the ‘Great Conductors’ series, Serge Koussevitzky directs the Boston Symphony orchestra in recordings made between 1946 and 1949, the last few years of his tenure as Music Director of the orchestra. He had a colourful life in his Russian homeland, combining his role as an outstanding exponent of the double bass with a fast growing reputation as a conductor and composer, while setting up his own publishing house. He stayed in Russia for a short time after the Revolution before setting up home in Paris. It was there that he began championing composers of his time, eventually arriving in the States where he became conductor of the Boston orchestra in 1924, already having reached the age of fifty. His tenure of the post created one of the world’s most highly respected orchestras, while throwing much energy into promoting modern American composers, Copland, Piston and Harris being among those who were indebted to his support. He also had considerable sympathy with those who were driven from their homeland in the years leading to the Second World War, Bartok and Martinu sustained emotionally and financially by his commissions. Today his name is revered, though reissues of his bounteous wealth of recordings are conspicuous by their absence. That Wagner meant a great deal to him comes in a rough-hewn and tempestuous overture to Der fliegende Hollander, and the expansive readings of the Act 1 Preludes to Lohengrin and Parsifal. There is spirituality in his subdued Good Friday Music from Parsifal, though I find his Siegfried Idyll too weighty in Wagner’s original context of a serenade for a chamber group. The disc closes with the Brahms Academic Festival Overture in a very ordinary reading, some rough patches of ensemble not helping. The orchestra was otherwise superb, its strings obviously its crowning glory. The Naxos restoration team again work wonders, though the original RCA recordings were nothing to get excited about.

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group