Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

The Seniors Review, October 2010

Bach lovers who also happen to be fans of the late Glenn Gould can catch up on his 1957 performance with the Columbia Symphony Orchestra under Leonard Bernstein through a re-release. It features “Partitas Nos. 5 and 6,” which he had recorded in 1956 but found unsatisfactory and recorded again in this version now available through Naxos. The sound is clean and clear, and should please the most fastidious Bach lovers.

Dominy Clements
MusicWeb International, June 2010

Recorded in glorious mono, there has to be a certain amount of interest in Glenn Gould the Bach performer when considering recordings like this, especially when it comes to something like the Concerto No.1 in D minor BWV 1052 with its rather scratchy string sound. Ideally, we’d have a whole sequence of reissues for these recordings all lined up, and an expert reviewer able to reveal all when it comes to the discs which present the best balance and least offence to our modern digital-hungry ears. I used to listen to this and other Gould concerto recordings on CBS cassettes, and the re-mastering and restoration on this Naxos disc seems to give a brighter, more etched sound. There are advantages and trade-offs with even subtle treatments of the sound in these recordings, and a comparison with the fugue recordings on this disc when compared to their appearance on the Sony 1955 Goldberg Variations disc SMK 5 594 shows the 1992 engineers favouring a rounder tone and less tape hiss. Mark Obert-Thorn’s Naxos rendition is also marginally higher in pitch, though we’re talking about fractions here. Normally there is a certain amount of discussion about the source material for these re-masterings, but there is no comment on the actual tapes used or what actions were taken.

Comparing different versions does make one realise how much difference certain types of approach make. Assuming the Sony re-issues use a similar balance for the other recordings, the advantages to this new version become apparent quite quickly. The ear has to forgive a greater hardness in the sound in the search for greater detail and a more direct communication of nuance and expression. It’s only when returning to the duller mix that you realise what is missing and find your ears longing for the more lively Naxos colouration.

As one might expect, Bach’s Concerto No.1 in D minor BWV 1052 does sound rather measured and dated in this 1957 recording, although the final Allegro is lively enough. The real joy is in Gould’s playing, which holds and drives the rhythms so effectively. Bernstein proves to be a sympathetic accompanist, and the so-called Columbia Symphony Orchestra, reckoned to be members of the New York Philharmonic Orchestra ducking contractual restrictions by using an assumed name, are decent enough. There is no denying that the combination creates its own atmosphere, and once you have forgiven the scrawny sound it is easy to become deeply involved in a very sincere performance of this great music, which in his short performing career was a staple of Gould’s repertoire.

After his renowned 1955 Goldberg Variations recording, Glenn Gould began recording Bach’s Partitas in February 1956 as a follow-up. Dissatisfied with these takes, Gould returned to the Columbia studios three months after the concerto recording to create the versions which were eventually released. These are remarkable performances which, controversial in their own time and respected rather than loved in some quarters these days, have as did so many of Gould’s recordings become an influential reference for pianists ever since. Indeed, even today they are seen as a benchmark reference for exciting Bach interpretation. Sometimes startling in their clarity, Gould’s Partitas showed how this music could be spectacular and stimulating, making full use of his remarkable digital dexterity in fast movements, phrasing sensitively in the gentle Sarabandes and dancing with a rhythmic joie de vivre elsewhere. One pleasant aspect of these solo recordings is that Gould’s incidental but constant singing is kept well in the background, and is not very distracting even when it does come through.

Being something of a Glenn Gould fan I would have to say that these and the rest of his Partita recordings are a must for any self-respecting piano collection. Those of you who have the impression that his is a rather dry and brittle approach to Bach should have a listen to his playing in the Toccata opening of the Partitia No.6. This is full of fantasy, and to my mind gives an almost operatic sense of narrative over its almost 10 minutes of duration. Follow this with the eloquent and restrained spread of chords and conversational counterpoint in the subsequent Allemande and I defy your heart not to melt—there, another convert. There is no doubt that the Partitas are the core of the programme on this disc, but don’t dismiss the concerto, and have a listen to the wide vista which Gould makes from the Fugue in E major in an entirely different approach to the version you will hear in his later complete Well Tempered Clavier. Glenn Gould defies fashion and will never lose his appeal with discs like these in the bargain section of your local shop. With these fresh sounding re-masterings this has to be the version to have.

David Denton
David's Review Corner, April 2010

Today many acknowledge Glenn Gould’s performances of Bach as of landmark status, though he remains the most controversial pianist of his generation. Few could argue that his account of the D minor Keyboard Concerto should form an essential part of any Bach disc collection. He played a modern concert grand with the staccato quality to reflect the instrument originally intended, the result being wonderfully crisp and cleanly delineated. His central Adagio is beautiful, while the outer movements are propelled with vivacity. Of course we had hardly reached the age of period correctness in 1957, and the accompaniment from the Columbia Symphony, with Leonard Bernstein conducting, could well have equally served a late 19th century score. Even for its 1957 origin the sound leaves much to be desired, though in the same venue a few months later, it faithfully captures his playing in the two Partitas. Gould was in the vanguard of the move towards mercurial readings of Bach’s fast movements, and the pure brio of his playing in both Partitas is exhilarating. At the same time he plays slow movements with a naive simplicity that is magical. By contrast I find the two Fugues from the Second Book of The Well Tempered Clavier rather lumpy. An adjunct to today’s period informed performances on the harpsichord, but a valued historic document.

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group