Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Daniel Schweiger
Venice Magazine, May 2003

"Thankfully, Shostakovich created a piece of typical brilliance, an aggressive, thrilling and incomparably beautiful work that would make him one of the greatest practitioners of the "low art' of film scoring. The Moscow Symphony Orchestra gives it their all in this new recording, thankfully without KGB minders on their backs. It's just their countryman's great music that brings out their patriotic best."

Roger Hall
Film Music Review, February 2003

"With the helpful 24 page booklet of background notes by Adriano, as well as his skilled direction of the Moscow Symphony Orchestra, this is a disc with much to recommend. If you're a fan of Russian film music, then you'll surely enjoy these two wonderful Shostakovich scores. Marco Polo deserves high praise for this excellent release. It has thus been designated as a CD of Special Merit."

Rob Barnett
MusicWeb International, February 2003

What have we here? Russian film music by Shostakovich. Two scores from the thirty-five he produced for the cinema industry between 1929 and 1970. This is the first recording of the complete score for The Fall of Berlin which Gauk conducted as a five movement suite for a Melodiya LP in 1952. We also hear the much shorter first complete recording of the suite from The Unforgettable Year 1919. The suite was recorded on LP by Alexander Gauk in 1956 minus the Assault movement (a pocket piano concerto) and the Intermezzo. You might remember the 'piano concerto' which is a sort of super concise version of Addinsell's Warsaw Concerto. It was the filler on Dimitri Alexeev's Classics for Pleasure LP (later CD) with the two Shostakovich piano concertos. The 1919 suite was prepared by Shostakovich's close friend, Levon Atovmyan.

The films each interleave a re-creation of history (war and insurrection) with a story of love and friendship. History, relentless and heroic and propagandised (though probably no more than by Hollywood), is thrown into some relief by the lives of ordinary people caught up in or trodden down by events. In fact the two spheres are complementary; there was no room for satire or personal dissent.

The Fall of Berlin music has its share of conventional gestures but certain tracks stand out. Beautiful Day and Stalin at Berlin Airport are brightly and forwardly sung (trs. 2 and 15). Alyosha by the River is magically hushed. Several times it seemed that the composer was looking back to Beethoven's Pastoral (trs. 2, 5). A feint in the direction of symphonic gravity can be heard in In the Devastated Village and The final battle (trs.7 and 13) looking towards symphonies 7, 8, 10, 11 and 12. More often than not the composer borrows familiar gestures from Borodin (Second Symphony) as in Main Title Part 2 and Storming Seelov Heights (tr. 9, 11) and from Rimsky-Korsakov in The final battle (tr. 13).

Waxman, Rózsa, Steiner and John Williams have written bumptiously regal music and Shostakovich pulls off the same trick in the Finale of the Berlin score and in the Tsarist preening of the Introduction of 1919. The 1919 score is not quite as unforgettable as the year it was meant to portray. Here the references are again to Razliv, Tchaikovsky and steppe-loneliness Slav gestures whether in gloomy reflection or hussar charges redolent of Miaskovsky (tr.23 1.47).

Can we now implore Marco Polo and Adriano to record as much as possible of Ovchinnikov's score for War and Peace? A DVD series of the Shostakovich and Prokofiev films would be welcome too.

If this is not quite essential Shostakovich it makes a self-recommending acquisition for any DSCH student. Superbly produced and executed by Adriano, Marco Polo, the Moscow Orchestra and the Moscow recording team.

"I would sincerely urge any fan of modern thundering orchestral scores to acquire some Shostakovich and these scores are an extremely accessible way to do so. The performance of the Moscow Symphony Orchestra is, unsurprisingly, excellent as is that of the choirs. The recording clarity and style is excellent. The notes on the films and their music are interesting and useful, it's unlikely that anyone buying the set will have seen or ever have the chance to see them, but the musical legacy is well worth hearing."

Andrew Keech
Music From The Movies

"This CD contains two impressive scores that are played intensely and brilliantly by Adriano and the Moscow Symphony Orchestra. With the mini-upsurge in interest in Russian film music in general and Dmitry Shostakovich's scores in particular, this is an interesting dimension to the current film scene and, for those who enjoy an explosive score, look no further."

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group