"The Egyptian is a landmark score, a one-time-only experience of two of our most talented maestros joining forces to create an epic and cohesive whole that still bears unmistakable signs of their indelible individual styles. More than that, it is actually thrilling and gorgeous music no matter who wrote what or how you hear it. But for those who are either low on cash-flow or unwilling to stick their necks out for two CDs, there are some distinct differences here that make me prefer the [Marco Polo] as a listening experience, and may serve to tip your own scales one way or the other."
"This is an awesome recording of a remarkable score: two great composers-Bernard Herrmann and Alfred Newman-in a singular collaboration that brought out the best in both. ... The old Decca recording...rewritten and condensed, and in dim monaural sound with heavy does of reverberation, is made obsolete by William Stromberg's brilliant re-creation; the Moscow ensemble might as well be the 20th Century Fox Studio virtuosi, so closely have they replicated that orchestra's distinctive sound. There isn't a false step in the pacing, the playing, or the superlative sound.If you've been tempted to 'try out' one of Marco Polo's film score series but haven't done so yet, now is the time to take the plunge. This will be remembered a their finest effort yet and one of the best film score re-creations of this or any year."