Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Michael Jameson, August 2001

"Carl Reinecke's Symphony No. 1 (1858) is seldom performed, so it's useful to have Alfred Walter's fine recording with the Rhenish Philharmonic available at budget price. Orchestral playing is highly proficient throughout as Walter leads a vigorous and lucid account distinguished by many agreeable touches of individuality, especially from the orchestra's excellent woodwind section. The symphony typifies the early German Romantic genre and shows the distinct influence of Mendelssohn. In outline, it's entirely classical, with a strongly melodic sonata-form first movement followed by a rondo Andante comprising five main sections. This latter movement contains the best moments in the piece, and Walter obtains some fine playing here, with warmly rounded string tone and elegantly plaintive wind solos. Next comes the Scherzo, complete with a rustic-sounding Grieg-like trio section and a competent if not terribly exciting finale, filled with lively, underdeveloped ideas.

"The fillers, music from Reinecke's five-act opera King Manfred (1866), provide the program's best music. The overture is superb, striking in its orchestral virtuosity (shades of Weber here) and interspersed with several eloquently lyrical sections, notably for horn and cello. The prelude to Act 5 is intensely poetic and suggestive of early Wagner. Walter and the Rhenish Philharmonic give accomplished performances of each, and despite the earnest predictability of the first symphony, it's constructed strongly enough to make it worth an occasional hearing."

Raymond Walker, August 2001

"Carl Reinecke is often remembered for the cadenzas that he wrote to other composers' classic concertos rather than for his own compositions. He was, however, a prolific writer of around 300 works. He was born at Altona near Hamburg, the son of a teacher of music. At 11 he made his debut as a violinist and at 12 made his first public appearance as a pianist. Later, he toured North Germany as a pianist and this led to his appointment as court pianist in Denmark (for two years) before turning to the education of others.

"In 1851 Hiller invited him to join the staff of the Cologne Music School where he worked for the next three years. On the recommendation of Hiller and Gade Reinecke was appointed director of the Gewandhaus concerts in Leipzig and became professor of piano and composition at the Conservatorium there. As a friend of Mendelssohn, Brahms and Schumann he devoted much of his time to performances of their music whilst, as a pianist, he had a reputation as an interpreter of Mozart.

"Reinecke's Symphony No. 1 began with sketches made five years earlier in 1858. It underwent some rewriting before being performed in Leipzig under the composer's direction in October 1863. Its structure follows a similar pattern to Haydn's symphonies but in orchestration has leanings towards Mendelssohn with melody and harmony more in line, as one might expect, with Gade and Schumann. The first movement, in romantic sonata form, starts with a ponderous opening (Lento) but gathers momentum to open into an Allegro con brio where the orchestral forces majestically herald a stirring main subject of soaring strings with Mendelssohnian overtones. A tranquil Andante follows of five-section rondo form. A thread of melancholy weaves through it with a theme of innocence (typical of Reinecke and strongly reminiscent of Mahler's Adagietto from his 5th symphony). A chromatic passage later gives a clear hint of Schumann. A Scherzo provides contrast with the previous movement with its strong opening rhythm and cheery character. This then relaxes into a flowing melodic line before breaking into the sprightly opening. The Finale, again in sonata form, an Allegro ma non troppo with short development leads to an Allegro molto quasi presto which provides us with a bright and technically proficient conclusion.

"King Manfred was written as a 5 Act Romantic Grand Opera to libretto by Roeber. The opera concerns the fate of King Manfred of Sicily who fell in battle against Charles at Anjou. The heavy subject matter caused the opera to disappear from general repertoire (despite being published) but its Overture and the Preludes were to be heard in concert halls up to the turn of the century. The Overture is one of Reinecke's most important works. In it he replaces the musical content of the opera's score with a character-sketch of Manfred in the manner of Beethoven's Leonora or Wagner's Faust. One is aware of lyrical melodies for horn and cello, the strumming of a minstrel's harp against a romantic theme and brass fanfares to herald the presence of powerful armies. The Prelude to Act IV is particularly atmospheric with solo violin playing a theme with legato harp and orchestral background. The Prelude to Act V opens with a short introduction to anticipate a darkness of impending catastrophe, that marking the death of Manfred. A lyrical passage brings a release from tension and presumably is used to make us aware of the good qualities of this King. The Ballet Music was included to meet French rather than German tradition. It comprises two numbers. Without a synopsis this piece is difficult to comment on. The pace of the first slow and lifeless number tends to drag and one wonders if its metronome marking has been accurately read. The second number is a bright and stirring dance more in keeping with the Slovaks than the Italians (despite a touch of Grieg here and there).

"The performances of the two works are excellent and the recording is well balanced. The Rhenish Philharmonic Orchestra plays with energy and competence under the fine direction of Alfred Walter. The notes give fair detail of composer and a short section on the works.

"This disc is one of a series first released on their more expensive Marco Polo label which is now transferred to the more accessible Naxos label... The transfer of label makes them now available at a very affordable price."

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group