Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Penguin Guide, January 2009

The Vermeer are a superbly equipped quartet with first-class ensemble and attack. These are recent recordings and are certainly highly recommendable…a considerable price advantage.

Jeff Simon
The Buffalo News, May 2006

One of the great recent versions of - arguably - the towering string quartets of the 20th century is by frequent Buffalo visitors the Vermeer Quartet. And because it's on Naxos, this two-disc set is budget priced. Three decades separate the composition of the first Bartok Quartet from the sixth and last. Not only is the stylistic diversity within them often much exaggerated but so too are the difficulties presented by the third quartet, which, for all its dissonance, is so structurally cohesive (it's the shortest at 15 minutes - half the length of the first, fifth and sixth) that it remains one of the most powerful works in the quartet repertoire.

What the much-traveled, much-recorded Vermeer Quartet brings to these quartets is irreplaceable, i.e., these four men are never flummoxed for a second by this music. You will never catch them, no matter how fiendishly demanding it gets, substituting sound for music. They never forget that the composer who, in revolutionary youth, pointedly (and theatrically) wore peasant boots, came of musical age as a contemporary of Strauss and Debussy. The result is a discipline and a suavity that elevates their Bartok cycle to a very high level.

Fanfare, September 2005

View PDF  

Classic FM, August 2005

View PDF  

Gramophone, July 2005

View PDF  

Tony Haywood
MusicWeb International, July 2005

"The greatest, most seminal string quartet cycle since Beethoven’s has done exceptionally well on disc. There are at least a dozen highly recommendable sets of the Bartók quartets now on the market, including some at around Naxos price. This new Vermeer cycle has its work cut out to make inroads.

On initial acquaintance, I feel a bit like I did about Marin Alsop’s Miraculous Mandarin, though maybe not quite as strongly; that is, some very good things in and among, but ultimately not enough bite and attack to make it truly memorable. The Vermeers produce a warm, homogenous sound that suits some passages more than others. They seem very much led from the front, as it were, with veteran Shmuel Ashkenasi’s first violin often dominating the texture. His smooth sound, with its rich vibrato, is quite romantic and singing, but lacks something of a raw edge at times.

The wisps of Debussy and Brahms that are just about still evident in the First Quartet help to suit the Vermeer’s expressive style. The first movement’s violin duet motif is beautifully phrased, and the polyphonic workings of the development section also emerge with clarity and an unforced eloquence. Likewise, the Second Quartet’s more daring territories (shades of Schoenberg’s Second Quartet here) are charted with the same sense of ease and line, so that one can bask in the harmonies rather than be brought up short by them.

Where things get muddier is in the trio of middle quartets, where Bartók’s astringency and dissonance need to pack a wallop. The Vermeers seem almost lax in what Paul Griffiths calls the ‘furious compactness’ of the Third Quartet, particularly when compared to, say, the Alban Berg Quartet, whose mid-1980s EMI set has long been my benchmark. It’s not particularly about tempo - although the ABQ do shave off well over a minute from what is only a 15-minute work - but more about tightness of rhythmic attack and crispness of phrasing. Similarly, the Fourth Quartet’s muscular opening, with its hints of Berg’s Lyric Suite, sounds just a trifle slack and lacking urgency. They do make some amends with an atmospheric lento third movement, the heart of the five-movement arch structure, but they are no match for the ABQ in the virtuosic scherzos that frame it, especially the famous pizzicato fourth movement or the prestissimo second.

The sound is a touch dry and close, which highlights some of the playing qualities mentioned above, but is remarkably consistent for what was a three year recording venture. Richard Whitehouse’s perceptive notes are, as usual, a model of their kind."

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group