Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Phillip Scott
Fanfare, July 2007

…this is one of the most fascinating and worthwhile issues in Naxos’s extensive “American Classics” series.

Recording quality is very good, superior to some other Russian sessions from this company, and performances are absolutely first-rate. © 2007 Fanfare Read complete review

Carson Cooman
Living Music Journal, May 2007

Without doubt, American composer Stephen Albert (1941-1992) is one of the greatest musical losses of the 20th century. Killed in a car accident in the prime of his career, he was in the midst of a producing works of profound significance to American music. A life-long New Yorker, Albert studied at the Eastman School of Music and the University of Pennsylvania; he taught at Stanford University and Smith College, before becoming professor of composition at The Juilliard School in New York City. He served as composer-in-residence with the Seattle Symphony in the 1980’s and fulfilled commissions from many major American orchestras and organizations.

Thankfully, most of Albert’s major works have now been recorded, although a number of those releases are unfortunately already out of print. This superb new disc on Naxos nearly completes the recording of his mature orchestral works. Albert’s next-to-last composition, the astounding clarinet concerto Wind Canticle (1991), was finally released two years ago on Albany Records in a strong performance by the Steven Schempf and the Bowling Green Philharmonia. I cannot recommend that recording highly enough. Wind Canticle would be one of my “desert island” compositions, as it sums up everything Albert does best in one compact, wonderful work. Thankfully, Naxos has decided to include music of Albert in their admirable “American Classics” series. This widely distributed new release should provide some much needed visibility for these important pieces.

Albert’s first symphony, RiverRun, was first released on Delos in an excellent performance by its commissioners, the National Symphony Orchestra under Mstislav Rostropovich. Well more than half of Albert’s compositions are inspired by the writings of James Joyce, in particular Joyce’s last major work, the fantastical novel Finnegan’s Wake. Given the depth of allusions and endless wordplay that fill the novel, it is not surprising that it could provide fertile ground for ongoing musical inspiration. In some of his “Joyce” works, Albert sets the actual texts to music. The symphony, by contrast, is a purely musical piece. However, it does share much of its musical material with the extended song cycle TreeStone (1983) for soprano, tenor, and twelve players (also recorded on an out of print Delos CD by the New York Chamber Symphony). Thus, if one knows TreeStone, one knows all sorts of words for the melodies that appear within RiverRun.

Structurally, the work overtly resembles a typical four movement symphony – Rain Music, Leafy Speafing, Beside the Rivering Waters, and River’s End – each movement with a title from Finnegan’s Wake. The use of myriad ostinati throughout the piece portrays the ever-present running river.

The opening movement sets up the thematic material of the entire work and establishes the driving pulse of the river. The second movement is quieter and slower, with no brass or percussion. In this movement, ostinato textures feature prominently as backdrops for solos, duos, and trios.

The third movement is perhaps the most striking; it is formally structured as a scherzo and trio (actually more of a “march and scherzo” as described by Albert). The most wild and fun music in the work appears within this movement. A tune is quoted that was adapted by James Joyce from an Irish folk song and was originally notated within the text of Finnegan’s Wake. Albert combines Joyce’s tune with his own material, often deliberately set up to be off-kilter in rhythmic alignment. The movement depicts an Irish wake as seen through a hazy nightmare. The piano and orchestral saxophone feature prominently and add to the drunken, reeling atmosphere. The “scherzo” material, by contrast, is whirling and child-like, bringing back material from the earlier movements. The march theme returns to end the movement in a stupor, before it all fades away to nothing.

The final movement builds in intensity throughout; it is cast in three primary sections, each separated by contrasting interludes. The movement draws together music from all the previous three movements, developing it dramatically before finally disappearing in a water-filled coda.

The work, which was awarded the 1985 Pulitzer Prize in Music, is one of Albert’s most distinctive compositions. This is one of the most important American symphonies of the second half of the 20th century and is a work of fascinating shapes, colors, and ideas – holding the interest of the listener for every moment.

Albert’s Symphony No. 2 was his last composition. He wrote it on commission from the New York Philharmonic and left it unfinished at his death. His friend, composer Sebastian Currier, was asked by G. Schirmer (Albert’s publisher) and the Albert family to complete the work. In his excellent liner note to this release, Currier describes his process – which involved primarily fleshing out already detailed orchestration notes and adding some other minor additions based on Albert’s sketches and general style. What Currier makes very clear, however, is that the work was truly already “done” at the point of Albert’s death, and we are thus hearing the piece probably almost exactly as he intended it. Albert’s orchestration style throughout his entire career is very recognizable and consistent, which was also helpful to Currier in making any decisions about matters left unclear in the manuscript. Currier states his opinion that Symphony No. 2 represents a full flowering of romantic symphonic impulses in Albert’s language that had always been present, but kept somewhat “in check” in previous works.

Unlike the fantastical world of RiverRun, the second symphony is audibly a more “conventional” piece in many regards. The myriad ostinati that featured so prominently in RiverRun are not a part of the second symphony. Rather, rich melody runs throughout, constantly developing, and awash in Albert’s very characteristic orchestration and colors. During the late 80’s and 90’s (after the composition of RiverRun) Albert composed three concerti – violin (1986), cello (1990), and clarinet (1991). It is very possible that the composition of these concerti, with the focus on a solo voice with orchestra influenced Albert’s thinking towards the sort of instrumental melody that flowers throughout this symphony. This is the first recording of the second symphony, and we can be very thankful that this magnificent work is finally available on recording.

The thirteen minute first movement is deep in register and seriousness in purpose. A carefully delineated development trajectory drives the movement. The shorter (five minute) second movement, by contrast, is a scherzo, reminiscent of the musical world explored in RiverRun. The third movement (also about thirteen minutes) returns to the expressive world of the first movement, with rich, beautiful textures building to glorious climaxes. Unlike most of Albert’s other works, the symphony ends in a full-orchestra blaze. It is a deeply passionate piece, containing many beautiful melodies and employing a thoroughly affirmative and valedictory tone.

About Albert’s style, Currier writes:

When discussing musical form and structure, he liked to make the distinction between predictability and inevitability. To be predictable was simply boring. For him, the most intense, the most memorable points in a piece were those that were unpredictable, but nonetheless felt totally inevitable. Looking back, a life can seem that way too. Although one could endlessly wonder what his “Third Symphony” might be like, in the end it is great to have these two thoughtful, finely crafted and expressive pieces.

Despite being prematurely silenced, Albert left an output that contains some of the most significant American music of the century. Its lack of visibility in performance schedules of orchestras

David Denton
David's Review Corner, April 2007
p>Born in the States in 1941, Stephen Albert rejected the establishment who he viewed as propagators of music in direct line with those who espoused serialism. He believed they were forming a chasm between concert audiences and composers who were often funded by educational establishments and living in their own ivory tower. Though that led Albert to follow a career mainly outside of music, he still retained a following, often among the great performers of our time. One of those was Rostropovich who commissioned Albert to compose a work for the National Symphony Orchestra, the outcome being the RiverRun symphony. Though each of the four movements carries titles they are to describe the nature of the content rather than having a strict programme. The sum total is the story of life as pictured in the flow of the river. Stylistically it is very much a personal score that Albert would like to see as having come from the era of Gustav Mahler. To my ears the music is earthier, less easy to follow in its progress, and thematically wandering. On the positive side Albert had the knack of creating interesting orchestral sounds that are purely tonal in context. The work dates from 1983, and it was a further eight years before he commenced work on the Second to a commission from the New York Philharmonic Orchestra. The ghost of Mahler certainly walks through the long outer movements that surround a short brilliant scherzo, ideas flooding the scene leading to a rather loosely knit structure. Sadly after beginning work on orchestrating his score, Albert was killed in a car accident at the age of 51, and it was left to his colleague, Sebastian Currier, to complete that part of the composition. Both works are performed with a commitment that would have you believe the work is in the Russian Philharmonic's repertoire. Born in Kansas City, the conductor, Paul Polivnick, is a product of the Juilliard School as a violinist and conductor, and he was later a student of Walter Susskind and Franco Ferrara. He is now well known on the North American concert scene, and is presently Music Director of the New Hampshire Festival.

Scott Cantrell
The Dallas Morning News, April 2007

Grade: A

TRAGIC LOSS: Stephen Albert was only 51, and at the height of his compositional powers, when he died in an auto accident in 1992. This CD of his two symphonies underlines the tragedy, especially considering how much wonderful music the American composer might have penned had he lived longer.

JOYCEAN DREAMINESS: Composed alongside a song cycle using texts from James Joyce's Finnegans Wake, the First Symphony inhabits something of Joyce's stream-of-consciousness world. Although Mr. Albert disclaimed a forthright program to the piece, it certainly suggests a river's origins, liquescent swirlings and underlying power, with snatches of folkish tunes woven into its course.

NORDIC CLARITY: Eight years on, the Second Symphony is cleaner-cut, with a certain Nordic clarity and thrust suggesting influences from Sibelius and Nielsen. The notes were essentially complete when Mr. Albert died, but the orchestration was unfinished. Fellow composer Sebastian Currier completed the orchestration, not as precisely as Mr. Albert surely would have done, but at least giving us a sinewy and striking piece.

BOTTOM LINE: Strong, communicative music, well realized by conductor Paul Polivnick and the Russian orchestra and very well recorded.

Bob McQuiston
Classical Lost and Found, April 2007

Stephen Albert's music is at once traditional and contemporary, lyrical yet powerful and dynamic. He drew inspiration from the rich orchestral palettes of composers such as Stravinsky and Bartók, but his musical language is very much his own. At the time of his tragic and unexpected death in 1992, Albert had completed the first draft of his lush, evocative Symphony No. 2, which here receives its world première recording. Asked by Albert's publishers to complete the work, his colleague and friend Sebastian Currier was pleased to find it almost finished, with only the addition of expressive markings and some orchestration to undertake. It is coupled here with Albert's Pulitzer Prize-winning first symphony, RiverRun, one of many of his works inspired by the writings of James Joyce. As Currier writes in his booklet note,"Although one could endlessly wonder what his Third Symphony might be like, in the end it is great to have these two thoughtful, finely crafted and expressive pieces."

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group