Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Bradley Winterton
Taipei Times, February 2016

This is a grand and entirely laudable scheme, comparable in many ways to some of Shostakovich’s symphonies devoted to the sufferings of the former Soviet Union. © 2016 Taipei Times Read complete review

Philip Scott
Fanfare, August 2007

The first thing to note about this release is the presence of star violinist Cho-Liang Lin. He once had a contract with Sony; now he appears on the Naxos label, playing two contemporary concertos. Quite a coup! Like Cho-Liang Lin, Gordon Shi-Wen Chin was born in Taiwan (in 1957) where he now resides, working as a teacher, music director, and a very active composer. He has written symphonies, concertos, and chamber music including five percussion quartets. Chin studied in the US with Christopher Rouse, and his music displays much of Rouse's customary energy, without being quite so aggressive about it. Lin asked for a work for violin and string orchestra which could be played without a conductor, to program alongside Vivaldi's Four Seasons: the wittily titled Formosa Seasons was the result. Similarly, the substantial Double Concerto was composed for Lin and Asian-Amercan cellist cellist Felix Fan (who has one of the most impressively wide ranging biographies I have read). With performers of this caliber—and I include conductor Michael Stern—you would expect the music to be special, and it is. Chin's Double Concerto for violin and cello is, to my ears, the finest in that form after Brahms. (There aren't hundreds to choose from, I know, but my point remains valid: this is great music.)

Its first movement opens vigorously, and the close relationship between the two soloists is established at once: they appear in tandem, building chords through double stopping, occasionally imitating each other but rarely working in opposition. The orchestra responds with stabbing chords, almost goading the string soloists on to greater flights, but this uneasy atmosphere soon dissipates one of the many patches of striving lyricism that permeate this work. The lyrical quality comes into its own in the romantic second movement, pitting the soloists against impressionistic orchestral textures. Then energy resurfaces in the third movement, which is notable for a piquant and tuneful waltz segment. Finally, the long, varied fourth movement, beginning in dramatic fashion with brass-heavy chords, revisits most of the moods heard earlier as a way of summing up, while at the same time expanding the dramatic landscape. It is a very effective conclusion. My description of the concerto does not begin to do justice to the incidental beauties in the writing along the way. Chin employs a contemporary language: little of it makes one think of traditional Chinese music (except possibly a number of sliding glissandos in the slow movement)—but if you're a fan of string concertos that soar, this is for you.

Formosa Seasons is also a substantial work, far from a simple divertimento. Each of the four movements is based upon a poem written by the composer. The poems tend to be haiku-like in form, conjuring up distinctive images from Chin's boyhood in Taiwan. (Translations are included in the CD booklet.) The related music is episodic and pictorial, full of detail and spontaneous shifts of mood. The second movement, "Autumn," surges with an almost tangible momentum in the strings while Lin's violin flies above, soon melting into one of the composer's most plaintive episodes. (Aptly so, autumn being the most ambivalent of the seasons!) "Winter" employs sparer textures, while the finale depicts springtime's renewal through strength rather than mere prettiness. In all four movements the solo part is a gift: soaring, diving, and generally putting the violinist through his technical and expressive paces.

Lin relishes every challenge. The same may be said for Fan, his equal in every way in the Double Concerto. Stern leads the excellent Kansas City Orchestra with vigor and commitment. Recording quality is close-up in the house style: I wanted more space around the players in Formosa Seasons, and the atmospheric soundscape of the Double Concerto's second movement would surely benefit from a little distance, but the musical qualities of the disc outweigh this minor grumble.

Over the last few years, Naxos has released a lot of music by lesser-known composers, and it is sometimes hard to know where to begin. If you feel that way, start here: a rewarding disc, featuring superlative performers and the work of a first-rate composer. Bring on the symphonies!

Bob McQuiston
Classical Lost and Found, March 2007

Reading the album notes for this release one cannot help but be impressed by Taiwanese born composer Gordon Shi-Wen Chin's (b. 1957) stated desire to write meaningful music devoid of superficiality. He has succeeded in doing just that with the two modern sounding, but quite approachable concertos on this release. These world premiere recordings honor two Taiwanese-American soloists; veteran violinist Cho-Liang Lin and the up-and-coming cellist Felix Fan, whom you'll undoubtedly be hearing more about on the basis of his outstanding performance here. The double concerto for violin and cello is in four programmatically titled movements. The first, "Drifting Shadow", consists of highly agitated opening and closing sections surrounding a more rhapsodic central one, and may call to mind Samuel Barber's violin concerto (1939-40). The next, "A Flowering Sacrifice," is for the most part slow and repentant with occasional glissando sighs from the strings. A sprightly rondo, "In Expectation," follows providing an exhilarating contrast to what’s come before. The finale, "Yearning: A Sweet Torture," begins forcefully with a brief repeated motif played by the percussion. The soloists then enter into an increasingly heated exchange with the orchestra, interrupted periodically by additional percussive outbursts. The work ends peacefully as all the disputants resolve their differences and the soloists fade into the distance. The concerto, Formosa Seasons for Violin and Strings, was originally to be paired with Antonio Vivaldi's Four Seasons, but other than that there's no apparent association between the two. The first movement, "Summer," is sultry with virtuosic passages allowing the soloist to shine like the summer sun. "Autumn" opens in a restlessly driven manner and contains a rather catchy theme with a Jingle Bells rhythm before becoming quite meditative and ending quietly. "Winter" begins hesitantly, but the soloist soon dominates the proceedings only to be subdued by some heavy duty pizzicato passages from the orchestra. "Spring" bursts forth with rhythmic energy to spare, giving Lin a final opportunity to demonstrate his considerable talents. The shortest of Chin's seasons, it ends abruptly in medias res leaving the listener quite breathless. The composer creates a unique, appealing sound world in both of these pieces. Conductor Michael Stern and the Kansas City Symphony provide sterling support for the soloists, and the recorded sound from renowned audio engineer Adam Abeshouse is demonstration quality. This release is recommended to modern music enthusiasts and audiophiles alike.

David Denton
David's Review Corner, March 2007

Gordon Chin was born in Taiwan in 1957, but spent his formative musical education in the United States at the Eastman School of Music as a student of Samuel Adler and Christopher Rouse. He has since returned home where he is now an established and active composer, his catalogue of works including four symphonies, concertos, vocal works and a number of instrumental and chamber scores. The two concertos contained on this new release were written with Chio-Liang Lin in mind, Lin being the most internationally famous violinist from Taiwan. The Double Concerto dates from 2002, each movement carrying a descriptive title, and finds the composer working in a style derived from Western Europe, the pastoral slow movement having more in common with English music in the second half of the last century. It is a very well constructed piece working in that now familiar mix of tonality and atonality that may well point the way forward into the present century. Offering solos for both violin and cello it is essentially a concertante score where orchestra and soloists intermingle in creating the overall effect. Formosa Seasons came as a request from Chio-Lang Lin for a piece to play in concerts with Vivaldi's The Four Seasons. Scored for solo violin and a string orchestra, it is Chin's response to changing seasons and requires considerable technical expertise from all involved. I find it an engaging piece of modern music, Chin's fresh and inventive use of string sounds bringing a real breath of fresh air. The two works added together form a highly desirable disc. Both soloists are superb, and the very fine playing from the Kansas orchestra makes one hope Naxos will use them in their American Classics series. The sound quality is excellent.

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group