Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Steve Schwartz
Classical Net, June 2012

This CD presents early, middle, and late Arnold. All…show great finish, wit, and poetry within a small space.

You can see what in Lambert’s music appealed to Arnold, namely a sophisticated wit and use of vernacular material. This movement ends as lightly as the pop of a soap bubble.

The Suite Bourgeoise, for flute, oboe, and piano—yet another World War II work—we can compare directly to the Grand Fantasia. The level of invention runs much higher than what one normally encounters in such works, and the quality of the instrumental writing reveals a master.

Arnold composed his Divertimento for Flute, Oboe, and Clarinet for his friends…Keep in mind there are only three instruments, all pretty close in range. Arnold not only solves these basic problems, he creates a work of surprising depth, all through miniatures.

The 3 Shanties…stand as Arnold’s biggest hit among his wind chamber music. Each movement arranges a well-known shanty…The arrangements are brilliant and often slightly daffy…Arnold tosses off roulades of jaw-dropping counterpoint and fills the work with bright, scintillating textures. The work bounces along to an elated, slightly manic, conclusion. It should raise a smile…it’s a fine disc. © 2012 Classical Net Read complete review

Penguin Guide, January 2009

Sir Malcolm Arnold has always been an enthusiastic composer of wind music. East Winds, made up of talented young wind-players, here give brilliant performances which consistently bring out the wit of the writing. This is a well-chosen and wide-ranging selection of works which make up a delightful sequence. Maybe the best known of all these works is one of the earliest and shortest, the Three Shanties, Op. 4, written in 1942 when he was still playing in the LPO, a piece intended to entertain his colleagues. Already the virtuosity of the writing is astonishing, displaying Arnold’s great gift for writing complex counterpoint which is yet immediately accessible. That also applies to the equally winning performance of the Op. 35 Divertimento…East Winds bring out the fun delectably.

Edward Greenfield
Gramophone, August 2007

The East Winds blow in with a delightful Arnold selection

As a professional player, leader of the trumpet section in the LPO early in his career, Sir Malcolm Arnold was an enthusiastic composer of wind music. East Winds, made up of talented young players, here give brilliant performances which consistently bring out the wit of the writing. Even if this doesn't evolve into a series covering all of Arnold's wind music (as three Hyperion discs from the Nash Ensemble do), this is a well chosen and wide-ranging selection that makes a delightful sequence.

Maybe the best-known is among the earliest and shortest, the Three Shanties, a piece written to entertain his colleagues in 1942 when he was still playing in the LPO. Already the virtuosity of the writing is astonishing, displaying Arnold's great gift of complex counterpoint which is immediately accessible. East Winds time these charming pieces perfectly, with tiny hesitations in exactly the right places to heighten the wit.

That, too, applies to their equally winning performance of the Divertimento, East Winds relishing the little clarinet scoops in the first movement. They also have a recording which in its openness has splendid separation.

Other performances follow the same pattern, including the arrangement of sections of Arnold's music for the film Hobson’s Choice. It says much for the performances and the accessibility of each work that the whole sequence makes such easy listening.

Michael Cookson
MusicWeb International, May 2007

Goodness me, there has been some vitriol spouted about the music of Sir Malcolm Arnold over the years, a composer who divides opinion like few others. Music writer Mark Morris in A Guide to 20th Century Composers, writes, “Malcolm Arnold is something of an anomaly in modern English music: a prolific, sometimes brilliant but often depressingly banal composer totally out of touch with the developments of the second half of the 20th Century.”

The BBC hierarchy for many years seemed to ignore Arnold’s music. People were convinced that Sir William Glock, then BBC Controller of Music was pursuing a vendetta against him and that his music had been blacklisted. The influential Sir John Drummond who was BBC Controller of Music 1985-92; BBC Radio 3 Controller 1987-92 and Director of the BBC Proms Concerts 1986-95 clearly thought that Arnold’s music was not the way forward. Sir John informed me in his own inimitable way how he believed that Boulez, Henze (his friend) and Birtwistle were today’s masters and that he could not convince himself that Arnold was in the same league.

The current resurgence in interest in Sir Malcolm’s music is partly down to the celebrations that were being planned for his forthcoming eighty-fifth birthday and the usual phenomenon of interest that follows shortly after the death of a composer; but not exclusively so. In the last decade or so the tide seems to have been turning in favour of Sir Malcolm&rs quo;smusic with arguably a backlash against those fashionable progressive and modernist composers for whom he had been shunned. So for some, Arnold&rs quo;s music of infectious melody and mad cap hilarity had become passé, but for his loyal band of supporters his love of communicating sheer entertainment to the listener remained an enduring passion.

Few composers have Arnold’s innate ability for effortlessly conveying that splendid blend of wacky humour and nervous anxiety; slapstick and intense pain, infectious melody and deep passion, spirited rhythms and potent drama. Many readers will be awareof the deep personal difficulties in Arnold’s often troubled life and with his highly melodic, dance influenced and wit infused music, tears, pain and anguish are never far away. A month or two ago in a review of a Franz Liszt disc I recall writing, “the contrasting demands of Liszt’s inconsistent genius, with writing that is brilliant one minute and bordering on the vulgar the next.”Whilst not placing Arnold in the same elevated league as Liszt the same sentiments could be said to apply to the frequently uneven quality of Arnold’s music.

This is a valuable release from Naxos for Arnold collectors as it comprises twelve wind chamber scores, five of which are claimed to be world premiere recordings. Sir Malcolm wrote a large body of works for wind instruments and the label will require more than this single release to encompass all his compositions. I look forward to a further issue from these excellent performers of the remaining wind works; such as the Trevelyan Suite, Op. 96; Quintet for flute, violin, viola, horn and bassoon,Op. 7; Trio for flute, viola and piano, Op 6 et al.

The first score on the release is the Wind Quintet for flute, oboe, clarinet, horn and bassoon, Op.2. Arnold composed the score in 1943 for his friends in the London Philharmonic Orchestra and the work was lost for over sixty years. It was only after the death of clarinettist Stephen Walters, who played in the first performance, that the score and parts were discovered in his possessions. In the hands of East Winds the good humoured Allegro has a jazzy feel with lots of hectic activity and there is a spiky, almost repetitive quality to the brief Scherzo. Marked Alla Marcia the finale contains sardonic marching rhythms and a pseudobugle reveille, where it seems likely that Arnold is parodying the brutality of the Second World War.

Arnold wrote a significant amount of music that featured the clarinet and the Divertimento for 2 Clarinets, Op. 135 from 1988 is the most recent work on this release. For some unknown reason the six movements have been spread across the release to, “form a series of interludes.” It is hard to fault clarinettists Victoria Soames Samek and Allison Rosser who provide their best endeavours in this rather unmemorable and uneventful score. Notable is the short third movement Vivace contains virtuosic playing of reckless abandon. Marked Lento the fourth movement appears to be divided into two sections; the first a relaxing section, followed by a perky and brisk second. Of reasonable interest is the fifth movement, another Vivace, that pursues an agitated mood.

Dream City was originally a piano piece composed by the teenage Arnold on Christmas Eve in 1938 whilst a pupil at the Royal College of Music. Paul Harris has arranged the brief piano score for wind quintet that I assume employs the instrumentation of flute, oboe, clarinet, horn and bassoon. The confident players of East Winds provide a tender and relaxing interpretation of this melodic score.

The year 1953 was an extremely busy and highly productive year for Arnold. Based on the original 1915 stage comedy by Harold Brighouse, Hobson’s Choice staring Charles Laughton and John Mills, and directed by David Lean was one of several film scores he wrote that year. The Hobson’s Choice: Overture has been arranged by Uwe Radok for wind octet, it seems for pairs of oboes, clarinets, French horns and bassoons. Prominent throughout is the jaunty theme that seems to mimic Charlie Chaplin’s comical bow-legged dance-walk.

The Grand Fantasia was composed in 1940 and is a most impressive work in which Arnold recycles themes from his various film scores. Although no expert on Arnold’s film scores I keep hearing themes from the series of St. Trinian’s films, the fictional girls school, conceived by cartoonist Ronald Searle. Although we are not told the Grand Fantasia is a trio scored for flute, clarinet and piano. Using contrasting tempi the work is an eclectic blend of various musical styles. A theme reminiscent to that used to represent St. Trinian’s spiv Flash Harry and played on a pseudo pub piano is first heard at 2:22-2:40; followed by tango infused music at 4:19-5:32; then a jazzy clarinet solo played by Victoria Soames Samek at 5:41-6:03 and 6:42-7:05 and fair ground fun and frolics at 7:45-8:20.

Composed in 1940 thescore titled Overture was probably intended as an opening movement of a larger work. We are not informed of the original instrumentation but here Uwe Radok has made a wind octet arrangement it seems for pairs of oboes, clarinets,French horns and bassoons. Written in the war years the Overture proves to be an agitated and frenetic work with lots of aggression and warlike chords and melodies.

A masterwork of the genre, Arnold wrote his Suite Bourgeoise for flute, clarinet and piano in the early war years around 1939. Evidently the score was lost for fifty or so years and only came to light again in 1996. The five movement work commences with a hot and sultry Prelude containing a sunny Mediterranean feel, followed by the warm and lyrical Tango subtitled ‘Elaine’ that concludes in a pastoral vein. I found the central movement titled Dance (censored), originally called Whorehouse, evocative of the bright lights of a bustling city scene and the passionate Ballad has a cocktail bar feel to the piano writing. The Suite Bourgeoise concludes with an attractive movement titled Valse (Ugo) of swirling, good humoured music.

I heard the Suite Bourgeoise superbly performed in recital last year at my local music society by the ensemble Intriplicate in an arrangement of flute, oboe and piano. Intriplicate are a young Manchester-based trio formed in 2001, comprising flautist Claire Fillhart, oboist Sally Richardson and Claire Dunham on piano. A delightful recording of the Suite Bourgeoise is the recently released performance from flutist Nancy Ruffer, oboist John Anderson and Helen Crayfordon piano. Recorded in 2006 at Potton Hall, Suffolk this highly desirable releaseof ‘British Music for flute, oboe and piano is available on Dutton Epoch CDLX 7181 (c/w Eugène Goossens Pastorale et Arlequinade; Dring Trio; Musgrave Impromptu for flute andoboe; Bennett Sounds and Sweet Aires: McGuire Three Dialogues forflute and oboe: Samuel Shadow Dance).

The Scherzetto arranged here for clarinet and piano began its life as part of the 1954 comedy film score You Know What Sailors Are featuring Donald Sinden and Michael Hordern. In this excellent performance from Victoria Soames Samek and pianist Paul Chilvers I experienced the Scherzetto as a vibrant score with an exceptionally easygoing and cheerful nature.

The Fantasy for solo clarinet, Op. 87 was composed in 1966 as a test piece for the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra International Wind Competition. Soloist Victoria Soames Samek plays the Clarinet Fantasy with accomplishment in what proves to be a reasonably appealing work that blends agreeable melody and occasional quirky rhythms with realistically technical difficulty for the clarinet.

The miniature Fantasy for flute and clarinet was composed as a present for his children Katharine and Robert to play together. Written in the early 1960s, a successful time for Arnold, who had a few years previously in 1957 been awarded an Oscar for best music score for the David Lean film The Bridge on the RiverKwai. Similarities to the Double Fantasy have been identified to the title music from his contemporaneous score to Bryan Forbes’s 1961 film Whistle Down the Wind. This is superb woodwind writing from Arnold with a haunting main theme played by flautist Judith Treggor against VictoriaSoames Samek’s equally memorable bass line.

Cast in six short movements the Divertimento for flute, oboe andclarinet, Op. 37 was composed by Arnold for his friends Richard Adeney; Sidney Sutcliffe and Stephen Walters who gave the premiere of the work. In 1952, the time of his successful score to the David Lean film The SoundBarrier, Arnold was at the height of his compositional powers and the Woodwind trio reveals itself as a classic example of the genre. Ifound the opening movement an Allegro energico witty and melodic, the Languido sad and yearning that grows in intensity with a rumbustious central Vivace. The Andantino is a passionate and tender piece,the Allegretto semplice has a fanfare evocative of a Middle-Age jousting competition and I enjoyed the nostalgic seriousness of the final movement Piacevole.

With the fear of sounding repetitive yet another masterwork is the 3 Shanties for Wind Quintet of flute, oboe, clarinet, hornand bassoon, Op. 4; Arnold’s most frequently performed wind score. The 3Shanties was composed in 1943 and first performed by the wind quintet of theLondon Philharmonic Orchestra during a lunchtime shift in the strange surroundings of an aircraft hangar at Filton Aerodrome, Bristol.

Each of the three movements uses a traditional shanty: the first utilises What shall we do with the drunken sailor?, the second Boneywas a warrior and the third uses Johnny come down to Hilo. The outer movements leave the shanties at several points, and in the opening Allegrocon brio we hear an Argentine tango; what sounds like a Scottish reel and a Hillbilly hoedown. Arnold takes a rest in the central Allegretto semplice which is slow and relaxing. The concluding Allegro vivace is rhythmic and scampering and includes a waltz and a bossa nova.

The 3 Shanties for Wind Quintet is a popular chamber work and there are a few versions available in the catalogues. I note that the Nash Ensemble has recorded the 3 Shanties on their all Arnold disc titled ‘Chamber Music Volume 3’on Hyperion Helios CDH55073. In addition clarinettist Emma Johnson on her disc Arnold ‘ Clarinet Works’ has also recorded the 3 Shanties on ASV CDDCA922.

The five musicians of East Winds together withtheir guest players perform Arnold’s wind chamber music with fine accomplishment throughout. It is hard to find fault with these fresh and engaging interpretations that have the spontaneous feel of a live performance. The timbre of the instruments is very well captured by the Naxos engineers with only the barest amount of fierceness from the horn. Those looking for a recording ofArnold’s wind chamber music have no need to look elsewhere.

Carelessly some of the composition dates are not mentioned in the bookletnotes. One has to deduce the scoring of the Wind Quintets, Op.2 and Op. 4 and there is no information whatsoever about the instrumentation of the Grand Fantasia. Much of this essential information can be obtained from the Malcolm Arnold website.

On this Naxos release Sir Malcolm is in his element with these excellently performed wind chamber scores and I was with him all the way.

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group