Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

David W Moore
American Record Guide, May 2011

this is a fine example of music by a richly imaginative composer, played with warmth and accuracy.

To read the complete review, please visit American Record Guide online.

WRUV Reviews, January 2011

M. Weinberg (1919–1996) wrote highly variable pieces for cello. Not atonal, but not completely lyrical, some edginess. Interesting!

James Manheim, January 2011

The music of Soviet Russian composer Mieczyslaw Weinberg (also known as Moises Weinberg) has enjoyed a modest revival as the issues surrounding who left for the West and who stayed and made the best of a bad situation begin to recede. The music on this fascinating album reflects that schism in several ways, and the notes by Latvian-born cellist Josef Feigelson (in English only) will be worth the price for students of Soviet music. Feigelson is, for now, the champion of the 24 Preludes for solo cello, Op. 100, and the story of how he came to perform and record them is illustrative in itself. After finding them in a small-town music store, he prepared to leave the Soviet Union himself. As he scheduled his final recitals in the country, pianists regarded him as a defector (although his emigration followed legal channels) and refused to perform with him, so he turned to Weinberg, whom he had previously disdained as an “official” Soviet composer. Later he learned that Weinberg had written the preludes (and the shorter Sonata for solo cello No. 1, Op. 72, that rounds out the program) for Mstislav Rostropovich, who refused to perform them after he left for America. In response to Feigelson’s question, Rostropovich angrily called the non-dissident Weinberg a coward. But the next generation often can see past the individual choices to the music, and Feigelson is unlikely to be the last cellist to perform the preludes. For players, they have the attractive feature of being susceptible to slicing and dicing in several different ways. They might be thought of as a mixture of the Bach and Chopin prelude-set concepts, using a variety of 20th century techniques (none, of course, too adventurous, but this isn’t socialist realism, either). That is, they ascend through the keys, or at least tonal centers, beginning with C, but each prelude is also a study in a certain texture or motive and its possible implications. A sensitive and committed cellist is a necessity, and Feigelson definitely qualifies as one, but these are not showpiece works. Originally recorded in 1996 with decent sound from a New York college recital hall and released on the Olympia label, this was a fine choice for reissue on Naxos, with its focus on neglected national styles.

Robert Reilly
CatholiCity, December 2010

Naxos has reissued an Olympia CD of Weinberg’s 24 Preludes, Op. 100, and Solo Cello Sonata, No.1, Op. 72, with cellist Josef Feigelson. These works are even more redolent of Bach and have the advantage of the cello’s full, burnished sound. They are perhaps more immediately attractive than the solo viola music but require just as much concentration. I think only great composers try to write music this spare and this deep (Naxos 8.572280).

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group