Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

James Harrington
American Record Guide, July 2010

Shostakovich could easily have followed in the footsteps of the illustrious line of 20th Century Russian composer-pianists (Scriabin, Rachmaninoff, Medtner, Prokofieff, plus a host of secondary talents). His pianistic skills by all accounts were world-class, yet his output of piano music is much less prominent in his output. This is not to say that its quality is anything less than superb—the Op. 87 set of 24 Preludes and Fugues remains one of the unquestioned masterpieces of piano literature. The Second Sonata has slowly crept into at least the periphery of regularly performed and recorded Russian piano sonatas. Written in 1942 during some of the darkest times of World War II, it is a very private and personal statement—quite the opposite of Shostakovich’s Symphony 7 from the same period. Ashkenazy’s recording is the best (Decca 1846, Sept/Oct 2004), and that should not be surprising, as he has conducted all 15 symphonies and performed most of the chamber music and a lot of the piano music.

Both examples here are good. Boyadjieva plays generally slower with less edge, but very musically; and McLachlan is closer to the Ashkenazy approach, but not quite at the same pianistic level, and the recorded piano sound does not match Decca’s. As a collection of Shostakovich piano music, Boyadjieva’s complete set of 24 Preludes in all keys, same order as Chopin’s, are just about a perfect companion to the sonata. Using the Three Fantastic Dances, Shostakovich’s Op. 5, to fill out the program gives us early, middle, and later music by the master. Her musicality and attention to melody might convince you that Shostakovich was clearly influenced by Rachmaninoff (I believe he was, whether he would admit it or not).

McLachlan’s program, titled Shostakovich and Comrades, is filled with music that just as clearly was influenced by Prokofieff. Shostakovich’s Sonata 1, written 16 years before 2, is a bombastic, extremely dissonant single movement work of considerable difficulty. McLachlan’s percussive touch and the less than warm piano sound seem apropos. Kabalevsky’s Sonata 3 is an enjoyable but rather tame work, sort of like Prokofieff required to produce music that would appeal to the masses.

Miaskovsky is not well represented on records, but his Song and Rhapsody is the most beautiful work here. Stevenson might seem a little out of place here, but his lyrical Recitative and Air on DSCH from 1974 is a welcome set of variations on the motive based on Shostakovich’s name. He composed a large Passacaglia on the same motive in 1960-62, also recorded by McLachlan (Divine Art 25013, May/June 2006). Shostakovich used it often: Piano Sonata 2, Quartet 8, Symphonies 10 & 15. McLachlan finishes his program with a blockbuster rendition of Shchedrin’s 1999 virtuoso transcription of his 1963 orchestral work, Tschastuschki. This is a true find if you want to explore lesser-known Russian piano music from the 20th Century.

Jim Leonard, January 2010

For her third international recording, Bulgarian-French pianist Lilia Boyadjieva has delivered a stunning recital of piano music by Dmitry Shostakovich. She opens her disc with a playful account of his early Three Fantastic Dances, followed by a powerful reading of his Second Piano Sonata, and concluding with a characterful interpretation of his 24 Preludes. In every case, Boyadjieva has the measure of the music. She doesn’t overload the Fantastic Dances, doesn’t shortchange the Sonata, and doesn’t either under or over interpret the Preludes. In every case, Boyadjieva’s steel-fingered technique and clear-eyed insights portray Shostakovich’s relatively under-programmed piano music in a very favorable light. Listeners might wish for more irony in the Dances, more muscle in the Sonata, and more wit and feeling in the Preludes, but no one could wish them more accurately played. Some listeners may already have favorite recordings of these works-one thinks of Emil Gilels’ magnificent Sonata, and no Shostakovich admirer would want to be without the composer’s own stylish reading of the Fantastic Dances. But listeners new to this repertoire could do far worse than to start with Boyadjieva’s disc, particularly in Artek’s crystalline recording.

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group