Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Email Password  
Not a subscriber yet?  
Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Penguin Guide, January 2009

Recorded at the Teatro Lirico in Cagliari in February 2002, the TDK DVD demonstrates the traditional qualities of productions in provincial Italian opera houses. Traditional costumes and sets consistently help to enhance the comedy in this lively production by Andreina de Porto. The comedy revolves round the sure-fire buffo performances of the veteran, Alessandro Corbelli, in the title-role (only half-singing, but acting superbly) and Roberto de Candia as Dr Malatesta, just as confident and singing the part full out. Eva Mei is an equally assured Norina, not as fresh-sounding as she once was, but still a strong performer, and with Antonino Siragusa as Ernesto rightly presenting him as something of an opportunistic layout rather than a conventional hero. After a fierce start, Gerard Korsten proves a warm and purposeful conductor, pacing the comedy well.

John Steane
Gramophone, February 2004

"A stylish performance...There's good taste at work in all aspects of the production...Here, all the stage-people know their business, making best use of their resources and reliable in supplying some pleasure for the eye.. Gerard Korsten conducts with feeling for rhythm, texture and singing line...The chorus numbers are particularly good, and all the ensemble-work is so well rehearsed that you might assume it was all happening of its own accord...there is plenty to enjoy - including a beautifully tuned performance of the notturno duet, with Siragusa softening magically. A confident recommendation.

Robert Levine

"This conventionally staged Don Pasquale from February, 2002 at the Teatro Lirico, Cagliari (originally staged by the Teatro Comunale, Bologna) is on the money. The sets (by Susanna Rossi Jost) are handsome, with a wide, blue sky watching over the action in Don Pasquale's elegant library, and a nice moody garden for the last scene, and it's all well lit by Claudio Schmid. Similarly, Roberta Guidi di Bagno's costumes are just right for people of this class in Rome in the 1750s. Even more important, director Stefano Vizioli gets the tone of this sometimes harsh, sometimes bittersweet, sometimes rollicking comedy just right. Pasquale may be foolish, but he's not a buffoon, and Vizioli makes us feel for him from the start. The famous slap-in-the-face from Norina in the last act can be a moment of terrible cruelty, but again, the director wisely has our Norina looking ashamed of herself, suddenly aware that her ruse may have gotten out of hand. Malatesta is young and not too slick, and Ernesto is likeable as well. The action never flags and there's none of the buffo exaggeration we've come to expect and loathe in this opera.

The singing is uniformly fine. Pasquale is sung by Alessandro Corbelli, who makes a specialty of these buffo roles, and he has the idiom--and the notes--down pat. The voice is impressive and he's as good when boasting in Act 1 as he is unhappy in Act 2. His duet with the natty, energetic Malatesta of Roberto de Candia in the last act is the showpiece it should be, and de Candia's round, bright tone goes well with Corbelli's duskier sound. And speaking of bright tone, tenor Antonino Siragusa sings Ernesto with absolute shine. The voice takes some getting used to, and in fact it may be an acquired taste, but it's a fine voice, with a solid upper extension to a ringing D-flat. Eva Mei's Norina is the centerpiece of the performance; her fluent coloratura, easy top, and slightly acidic tone go hand-in-hand with an easy stage manner and bright eyes--she listens as well as she sings. Conductor Gerard Korsten, new to me, has a natural affinity for the bel canto. His long lines are elegant and his appreciation for Donizetti's bubbly score is evident. He refuses to overstate either the comic or the maudlin characteristics of the opera and reaches an ideal balance. His orchestra and chorus perform with vigor.

The sound is ideal, with genuine stage separation and clarity, the picture is crisp, and subtitles in lots of languages are provided. An add-on is a half-hour of behind-the-scenes stuff, including rehearsals (at times with an alternate cast, sometimes in street clothes) and observations by the director and singers. It's as charming as the performance. Oddly, this opera has remained elusive to a truly great audio-only recording. This one, without making too much of a fuss over itself, is just wonderful."

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group