Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Email Password  
Not a subscriber yet?  
Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Glenn Hopp
AudioFile, November 2008

With this package David Timson and Naxos complete their ten-year project to record the entire Holmes writings by Conan Doyle. Sherlockians regard THE CASEBOOK with mixed feelings, being the last and probably the least of Conan Doyle's Holmes efforts. David Timson, however, excels in these respectful readings and more than compensates for the lesser material. He goes beyond voicing words clearly; he savors the language and gives attention to every phrase. The subtle use of music to mark setting changes is also effective. The collection concludes with a bonus story written and read by Timson ("The Wondrous Toy") on Holmes's encounter with the new gramophone and, by implication, the birth of the audiobook era. Winner of AudioFile Earphones Award.

Rafe McGregor, October 2008

With The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes II David Timson completes his reading of the complete Holmes Canon, ten years after the release of The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes I [Naxos AudioBooks NA315212]. It’s a task he’s fulfilled with dedication, erudition, panache and wit, proving himself to be one of the great “voice men”. He makes every character a distinct individual, without resorting to exaggerated mannerisms—except, of course, for those flamboyant types for whom exaggeration is a part of their personality. Mr Timson’s collaboration with Nicolas Soames, who has overseen the project from the start, ensures that the pacing is just right. Listening to these familiar tales you can appreciate how sure-footed Arthur Conan Doyle’s storytelling is, for the most part—and how an excellent reading can improve a poor story, such as “The Lion’s Mane” or “The Three Gables”. Mr Timson’s recording of the Canon is a triumphant achievement. This final instalment includes as a light-hearted bonus “The Adventure of the Wonderful Toy”, a new story by David Timson himself, with, as he says, just a hint of parody: it concerns the introduction of the phonograph to Baker Street, an aspiring American actor, and an alleged peculiarity of Queen Victoria. Like other Naxos recordings, The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes II can be downloaded at

(Roger Johnson is an acclaimed author, editor, and Sherlockian. In addition to his many other interests, he edits The Sherlock Holmes Journal and The District Messenger for The Sherlock Holmes Society of London.)

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group