Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Graham Lock
Early Music Today, June 2020

PERGOLESI, G.B.: Adriano in Siria (Pergolesi Spring Festival, 2010) (NTSC) OA1065D
PERGOLESI, G.B.: Adriano in Siria (Pergolesi Spring Festival, 2010) (Blu-ray, HD) OABD7098D

Dantone’s young soloists, relatively unknown, burn with conviction and sing superbly, with Lucia Cirillo, Annamaria Dell’Oste and Nicole Heaston truly spellbinding at times. Following Neapolitan custom, Pergolesi added an intermezzo, Livietta e Tracollo for comic relief and Dantone respects that tradition here: mezzo Monica Bacelli and bass Carlo Lepore dispatch the fun with skill and gusto. In fact, every aspect of this enthralling production is close to exemplary. © 2020 Early Music Today Read complete review

Bill White
Fanfare, July 2012

PERGOLESI, G.B.: Adriano in Siria (Pergolesi Spring Festival, 2010) (NTSC) OA1065D
PERGOLESI, G.B.: Adriano in Siria (Pergolesi Spring Festival, 2010) (Blu-ray, HD) OABD7098D

Adriano in Siria is a Baroque opera and a prime example of the genre of opera seria, a stylized form that was to dominate Italian opera production for nearly the entire first half of the 18th century. In 2010 the Pergolesi Spontini Foundation in Peri announced it would be helping to underwrite the production and video recording of all of Pergolesi’s operas and intermezzos, the first two of which are seen here. Interpolated between the three acts of Adriano is the short comedic intermezzo Livietta e Tracollo.

This production from the small regional opera house in Jesi is quite charming. All of the six young singers seen on the video sing exceptionally well in this music…The small Baroque pit band propels the action well…The intermezzo seen between acts of the main opera is quite charming as well. Two singers, including the only one here I’d ever heard of before, mezzo Monica Bacelli, drive the comedic action of this piece…it makes a refreshing break from the more serious opera.

This production is…a fascinating glimpse of a genre long dead, performed and sung well…It is much more compelling visually in the Blu-ray format. I enjoy it; you just might as well. Conductor Ottavio Dantone talks about the opera, the composer, and this production in the interesting bonus feature. © 2012 Fanfare Read complete review

John W. Barker
American Record Guide, May 2012

Pergolesi’s vocal writing is fundamentally melodic and pleasing…he filled the arias with the most technically taxing vocal fireworks…Dantone has assembled an impressive cast of young singers committed to stylistic integrity. They are marvelously apt at the demands for both virtuosity and acting. All of them are expert at embellishment. I found myself particularly drawn to Heaston, who can not only whip off the rapid passage work, but can also float a long, sustained note…Dantone has plainly worked diligently with them and gives them incisive leadership from the podium and harpsichord.…director Ignacio Garcia has staged the piece with imagination and dramatic force…Garcia was making a learned, ingroup allusion to the historical fact that the young Hadrian was a passionate hunter.

The two parts of Livietta e Tracollo were used for Adriano. It is a farce parallel to Serva, where two manic stereotypes, a soprano and a bass, move from hostility to romance. Bacelli and Lepore manage to sing quite musically…The filming of this production is visually versatile and quite spirited in its own terms. © 2012 American Record Guide Read complete review on American Record Guide online

Robert McKechnie
MusicWeb International, April 2012

Generalities are usually unsatisfactory. However one or two can be made usefully about the standard of singing. The diction of all is admirable. They keep an excellent musical line well focused on word and phrase at all times. They are totally involved in the opera plot whether singing, watching or re-acting to another. Heart and soul are put into their roles.

Marina Comparato, in the title role, has not the strongest voice, particularly in her lower register, but this is more than made up for in splendidly clear mid-note hitting, comfortable trills and confidant runs. Her first aria is of conventional length but her two later ones, sadly, are less the two minutes each.

Annamaria dell’Oste (Farnese, the part written for Caffarelli) has the highlights, with arias closing Acts 1 and 2. Lieto così tal volta (DVD1, tr.19) concluding Act 1 is accompanied by an oboe obbligato and pizzicato strings. Strong runs, impressive sound in her upper reaches and crystal clear notes distinguish this performance. With the oboe player placed at the side of the stage, the interaction of musical phrases between oboe and voice is absorbing.

Lucia Cirillo (Emirena) brings a warm tone with a soupçon of cream. She needs her telling facial expressions to accompany her character, pushed from Farnaspe to Adriano and back again with a hell-raising father. Good acting, expressive recitatives, coloured low notes and delightful diminuendo, mark a distinguished performance. Her voice and that of dell’Oste balance so well in the only duet.

Nicole Heaston (Sabina) earns the strongest audience applause for her aria Chi soffre senza planto (DVD1 tr.12). Rejected by Adriano, manipulated by Aquilio, she needs that acting and vocal versatility so well shown here. Great breath control for some deliciously long-held ringingly clear high notes which she can send floating around the auditorium; all that with excellent coloratura, of the non-firework variety, but no less satisfying for that.

Whilst not having quite the heft to power out his arias, Stefano Ferrari (Osroa), as the attempted havoc-wreaking Parthian, is a convincing character. Determined delivery with cogent stage movement, a timbre that is easy on the ear with some light colouring enrich his performance.

Two rousing arias for Aquilio are seized by Francesca Lombardi which she makes very much her own. Strong across all her register with vocal leaps to mid-note, energetic delivery and packed emotion.

I wish that I could muster the same enthusiasm for the intermezzo. For me the parody has lost much of its effect with the theatrical changes over the centuries. Livietta, cross dressed as a Frenchman, seeks revenge on petty thief Tracollo, cross-dressed as a pregnant woman. Livietta rejects Tracollo’s marriage offer. In the second part, Tracollo is disguised as an astrologer, a disguise that Livietta sees through. After more posturing, they reconcile. The music is ‘pure Pergolesi’, fresh, vibrant and tuneful: the singing and acting persuasive. The more experienced Monica Bacelli as Livietta and Carlo Lepore as Tracollo are on fine form. Lepore’s first act aria Ecco il povero Tracollo (DVD1 tr.27) shows his voice to good effect: not overwhelming but a deep colour over a wide register. Bacelli’s opening aria Vi sto ben (DVD1 tr.21) is sung with a fresh vibrancy. She brings a smooth tone, some gentle colouring and a deep sense of comic timing. Their duets are classic of this genre.

…excellently paced with a crisp, cogent, expressive Accademia. The intermezzo needs no set—it runs front of curtain, down the auditorium centre aisle and in and around the orchestra pit. That for the opera is a neat layout of ‘stones’ facilitating characters to overhear, or hide from, events front of stage. The prison is neatly depicted by descending curtains of chains. There is some obvious symbolism with a caged canary and a free flying raptor. As you can see from the cover above that the Romans are conventionally garbed. The Parthians are in muted colours. All very satisfactory and captured by effective camera work.

The performance is all and on this DVD it is benchmark standard. © 2012 MusicWeb International Read complete review

David Vickers
Gramophone, February 2012

PERGOLESI, G.B.: Adriano in Siria (Pergolesi Spring Festival, 2010) (NTSC) OA1065D
PERGOLESI, G.B.: Adriano in Siria (Pergolesi Spring Festival, 2010) (Blu-ray, HD) OABD7098D

a fine performance featuring the zesty playing of Accademia Bizantina. The arias for Farnaspe…are dramatically and musically accomplished, especially the gorgeous ‘Lieto così tal volta’… Emirena is sung superbly by Lucia Cirillo…and Nicole Heaston’s performance as Sabina is simply sensational, from her immaculate long-held high notes…to flawless wide leaps of an octave and a half and wonderful embellishments… This is an exceptionally fine production that offers a great deal of integrity and fascination. © 2012 Gramophone Read complete review on Gramophone

Berta Joncus
BBC Music Magazine, February 2012

PERGOLESI, G.B.: Adriano in Siria (Pergolesi Spring Festival, 2010) (NTSC) OA1065D
PERGOLESI, G.B.: Adriano in Siria (Pergolesi Spring Festival, 2010) (Blu-ray, HD) OABD7098D

Realised with vibrant, breathtaking musicianship © 2012 BBC Music Magazine

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group