Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Gavin Dixon
Fanfare, November 2013

WAGNER, R.: Meistersinger von Nurnberg (Die) (Glyndebourne, 2011) (NTSC) OA1085D
WAGNER, R.: Meistersinger von Nurnberg (Die) (Glyndebourne, 2011) (Blu-ray, HD) OABD7108D

The DVD of Die Miestersinger from Glyndebourne has proved that traditional stagings of this opera need not be drab or dull. David McVicar’s production, and Vladimir Jurowski’s musical direction, both turn the limited scale of the venue to the work’s advantage, increasing its intimacy without reducing its impact. The young cast is able to present the entangled love interests more credibly than the older singers more often cast, and Anna Gabler is a particular treat as Eva (she’s since reprised the role at Salzburg). © 2013 Fanfare

Andrew Quint
Fanfare, March 2013

WAGNER, R.: Meistersinger von Nurnberg (Die) (Glyndebourne, 2011) (NTSC) OA1085D OA1085D
WAGNER, R.: Meistersinger von Nurnberg (Die) (Glyndebourne, 2011) (Blu-ray, HD) OABD7108D

This David McVicar-directed Meistersinger represents Glyndebourne’s second Wagner staging, and it’s something special.

The Finnish tenor Topi Lehtipuu handles the part of David very effectively…Anna Gabler is a complex and passionate Eva…Michaela Selinger, the Magdalena, is perky and vocally appealing.

…Gerald Finley is a superb one. He happens to be the best singer here, but his acting is what makes this production so compelling.

The production is sumptuously lit and filmed…The sound is richly detailed with excellent vocal/orchestral balances. © 2013 Fanfare Read complete review

Ralph V Lucano
American Record Guide, March 2013

Finley feels every word he says with his entire body, yet nothing seems unnatural or exaggerated. And he sings gorgeously too…

Michaela Selinger’s Magdalene and Lehtipuu’s David are a joy both to see and hear.

Jurowski…[is] solidly behind his singers in the biggest moments. The orchestra plays well…this is…a riveting performance, beautifully filmed and captured in excellent sound. And Finley’s Sachs alone is worth the price of admission. © 2013 American Record Guide Read complete review on American Record Guide

Michael Scott Rohan
BBC Music Magazine, December 2012

WAGNER, R.: Meistersinger von Nurnberg (Die) (Glyndebourne, 2011) (NTSC) OA1085D
WAGNER, R.: Meistersinger von Nurnberg (Die) (Glyndebourne, 2011) (Blu-ray, HD) OABD7108D

David McVicar reminds us that this is an opera about youth and self-discovery © 2012 BBC Music Magazine

Jeffrey Kauffman, November 2012

Let’s face it: Richard Wagner was never one to let a simple declarative utterance stand when thousands of obfuscating words might otherwise suffice. This most labyrinthine of composers and librettists delighted in allegory, metaphor, mythologizing and a score (no pun intended) of other techniques which one assumes were utilized to subvert the rational mind and appeal directly to some other, greater, apprehension. How bracing, then, is it to come to Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg, Wagner’s very personal ode to music, and, in a way, obviously to opera itself, but to find the composer-librettist at his most transparent and accessible in the process. This is one of the few Wagner operas without a mythological or supernatural element trodding laboriously around the stage, and it is also singular among his own “approved“ oeuvre in that it has a decided, if somewhat dated, comedic element. But what is perhaps most remarkable about Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg is how autobiographical it is, and how Wagner refuses to couch that self examination in anything that makes the storytelling opaque and less self-referential. What’s all the more amazing about the clarity of Wagner’s conception and execution is that the composer was attempting to elucidate some of the most arcane philosophizing of all time, that of Schopenhauer, whose writing about Art (and specifically music) had deeply affected Wagner and led the composer to reevaluate many of his previous ideas about the role of various operatic techniques. Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg stands, therefore, as a sort of treatise on Wagner’s part, but unlike many screeds, it’s a completely (or at least mostly) undogmatic affair that posits the saving grace of music with some of the most luscious songcraft of Wagner’s illustrious career.

Anyone who has ever taken a college level Music Theory class will tell you there are rules to composition that have been codified over untold centuries and which uptight music professors are more than insistent need to be followed to a tee. No parallel fifths in voice leading, dominant sevenths must resolve either “naturally“ to their tonic or “deceptively“ up a step to the relative minor, tritones must contract to either a major or minor third, and so on and so forth, ad infinitum. Those proclivities are at the heart of Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg, at least by implication, and the ironic thing is of course that Richard Wagner was one of the most blatant rule breakers of all time, as is evidenced by one of the biggest bugaboos of advanced theory classes, namely properly identifying and analyzing Wagner’s so called “Tristan chord“. (I once infuriated my otherwise sanguine theory teacher by blurting out one of the more widely accepted analyses, that of an altered augmented sixth, when he passed copies of the music out one day, hoping to stump the class.)

In the 17th century of Wagner’s original conception (moved up a couple of centuries in David McVicar’s otherwise faithful production at Glyndebourne), Nuremberg was a place where the Meistersingers (master singers) have rather recondite rules that had to be followed if new entrants were to be allowed in their exclusive guild. A young upstart named Walther (Marco Jentzsch) shows up and promptly falls in love with Eva (Anna Gabler), the daughter of Pogner (Alastair Miles), who has promised his daughter’s hand in marriage to whoever wins the meistersinger’s song festival (think the Eurovision contest, only without television). That upsets the most rigorous rule follower of them all, Beckmesser (Johannes Martin Kränzle), who had assumed winning the contest was a foregone conclusion.

Wagner also brings a real life character to life in Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg, an actual historical figure named Hans Sachs, played by Gerald Finley in this production. Sachs serves as a sort of musical conscience of the opera, striking out against Beckmesser’s unthinking formalism while championing the intuitive inspiration of Walther. The character is also sort of bittersweet, with a deeply moving scene with Eva where he realizes that while she might settle on him for a husband, it’s Walther who has actually captured her heart.

The Glyndebourne Festival Opera was originally conceived to be a sort of English Bayreuth, but circumstances prevented the Christie family from really exploiting Wagner until they finally were able to produce Tristan und Isolde there in 2003 (the Blu-ray features a 2007 remounting). In fact the Festival is probably best known for its Mozart interpretations, compositionally a world or more away from the heavier (in every sense of the word) works of Wagner. But under the inspired direction of David McVicar, this Die Meistersinger von Nurnberg actually has an incredibly engaging lightness, which at the same time never negates the intrinsic message the opera wishes to impart. McVicar wisely keeps his directorial “vision“ to a minimum, staging the opera with a minimum of fuss and bother but with a gorgeous production design that places most of the action under the towering canopies of a church cathedral.

The singing in this production is largely impeccable, especially Finley’s Sachs, which is achingly, even heart breakingly, lyrical and well realized. Jentzsch’s Walther is a bit more problematic, but he’s an athletic and appealing presence who physicality helps to overcome some of his vocal shortcomings. Kränzle’s Beckmesser is appropriately dark and foreboding, but also inherently comical. The conducting of Vladimir Jurowski is a little on the brisk side at times, but he culls a really gorgeous sound out of the London Philharmonic Orchestra, with some incredibly lovely soli by some of the reeds.

Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg is presented on Blu-ray courtesy of Opus Arte with an AVC encoded 1080i transfer in 1.78:1. This is a very nicely sharp and detailed looking high definition presentation that benefits from the sumptuous production design, including Vicki Mortimer’s evocative sets and costumes. The full depth of Glyndebourne’s stage is utilized under McVicar’s direction, with the first act especially notable for its impressive depth of field, especially when the action takes place upstage. Most of the opera is well lit, meaning there aren’t any issues with shadow detail, something that routinely hobbles these live performance Blu-rays. Close-ups reveal abundant fine detail, including at times some of the makeup on the singers.

Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg features a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround mix as well as an uncompressed LPCM 2.0 stereo fold down. This is one of those rare instances where there’s a really noticeable difference between the two mixes, with the LPCM offering coming off as a bit anemic when compared to the much more robust and full bodied DTS-HD Master Audio mix. The 5.1 option offers superior fidelity, with a richly burnished orchestral sound ably supporting but never overpowering the singers. There’s not a huge amount of separation between the singers when they’re onstage together, but there is some appealing sense of ambient hall reverb in such scenes as the opening chorale when the ensemble is singing far upstage (and one assumes, also offstage). Dynamic range is also very wide.

Cast Gallery (1080i; 1:23)

Die Meistersinger von Glyndebourne (1080i; 8:22) is a great background piece on this massive Glyndebourne production, the largest in fact that Glyndebourne has ever attempted. Glyndebourne’s connection to Wagner and Bayreuth is detailed with various members of the Christie family.

Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg—An Opera With Baggage (1080i; 10:38) focuses more specifically on this particular production and what director David McVicar sought to create, including divorcing the opera from some historical elements that have hobbled the opera since its premiere. The opera’s status as a sort of “confessional“ by Wagner is also explored.

“Richard Wagner“ and “joyful“ are not words one usually associates with each other, which is what makes this often ebullient production of Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg so inviting. Lushly staged and expertly played and sung, this production makes a few minor tweaks (like the time frame) without ever sacrificing the central message of Wagner’s delightfully clear libretto. This may be a resolutely traditional production (at least for the most part), but that doesn’t mean it’s not bracing. This Blu-ray offers excellent video and superior audio and comes Highly recommended. © 2012

Lawrence Devoe, November 2012

This 2011 production is the Glyndebourne premiere of this beloved opera with a generally strong cast, musical direction and dramatic concept. Opus Arte gives us yet another beautifully shot video with superb sonics.

The cameramen have done a great job getting the perspectives of this relatively small stage and house just right. They have also taken advantage of the very telegenic faces of the young cast and make this a visually intimate production. The costumes and sets find the right amalgam and put viewers into a very believable 19th century German town. Colors and costumes are beautiful and all of the sets work to perfection.

Glyndebourne has wonderful acoustics and in this case you get to hear things in the score that are swallowed up by larger venues. Voices and orchestra are well balanced in the…score.

This is the BD premiere of Wagner’s masterpiece. I want to applaud the Glyndebourne festival for taking a chance with this new production. The casting decisions work very well for the visual creditability of the lovers Walther and Eva who are usually portrayed by singers much older than their stage counterparts…It also helps matters greatly that Finley, an accomplished lieder singer, brings a rarely heard lyricism to the older man role of Sachs…with the outstanding leadership of maestro Jurowski and the great overall production values, Opus Arte has presented a terrific alternative to the usual suspects. A definite must-watch and, for my part, a keeper. © 2012 Read complete review

Nicholas Sheffo
Fulvue Drive-in, November 2012

This Glyndebourne production impressed me…this tale of love, wealth and maybe fate with heavy religious undertones is handled admirably by Conductor Vladimir Jurowski with the London Philharmonic Orchestra. © 2012 Fulvue Drive-in Read complete review

David Denton
David's Review Corner, October 2012

Never can a standing ovation have been so richly justified as that given to Gerald Finley at the close of this elegantly staged performance of Die Meistersingers. Visually he has the good looks and virile appearance of a widowed Hans Sachs that is still able to attract the young Eva, and with that fact has fashioned a character who has much latent love within him and now finding himself in the position of helping the young man, Walther, to be crowned winner of the song competition that would thrust him into the arms of Eva. Vocally he is superb, his large and perfectly focussed voice able to open up almost from his first entry, and then go through his long second act scene with a passion and emotion that is so totally convincing. Anna Gabler is the very beautiful Eva, and she too is more than obviously torn between young love and the older man, which here brings to the final act both sadness and happiness. I am sure the hearts of many in the audience would have gone out to this Sachs. It does rather leave the Walther of Marco Jentzsch as rather a spare part in the story, and he fits into that role so admirably that Eva must have been out of her tiny mind to take him in preference to this Sachs. That he doesn’t make all that much of the Prize Song becomes incidental, particularly as he is surrounded by the more highly effective and attractive tenor of Tapi Lehtipuu as David, whose sub-plot romance with the stunning Michaela Selinger as Magdelene carries with it the feel of true love.  Mention must be made of the sharply drawn characterisation of Alastair Miles as Veit Pogner, and the dandified Beckmesser of Johannes Martin Kranzle. Though updated to the early 19th century, David McVicar’s 2011 production for Glyndebourne is visually stunning, the elaborate sets seemingly created without financial constraint, while the multitude of different and colourful costumes add much to our enjoyment. Maybe at times he adds a little bit more to the spectacle of the big scenes than was absolutely necessary, but the detailed acting of everyone on stage is the work of a remarkable producer. The London Philharmonic are superb and add much in the purely orchestral moments; the chorus singing is magnificent and the conductor, Vladimir Jurowski, keeps everything moving with suitable urgency. I suppose there was just too much happening on stage in the first and last acts for the film crew to bring everything to our attention, but they do a magnificent job, while the sound engineers have brought the best quality I have encountered on audio-visual disc. I know I will return to the discs countless times. There is also a standard DVD on OA1085D in both formats it takes two discs. © 2012 David’s Review Corner

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group