Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Robert Benson, June 2012

This performance could be considered definitive. Jorma Hynninen created the title role in 1997, and can be heard in a recording made more than a decade ago. He is moving indeed, particularly in the Epilogue as he faces the reality of death. The entire cast obviously is dedicated to this project, and Mikko Franck’s conducting could not be bettered. The simple sets and costumes do not detract from the music. This performance was recorded in October 2010 by the Finnish Broadcasting Company, and they did a superb job: video and stereo sound are excellent. The 23-minute bonus includes conversations with the composer, Hynninen and Franck. Check out this recording, a superb presentation of a gentle but powerful opera. © Read complete review

Allen Gimbel
American Record Guide, September 2011

Aleksis Kivi is regarded as Finland’s “national author”, creator of “the first major novels, plays and poems in the Finnish language”, according to the composer’s notes. He died of a combination of alcoholism, madness (said to be schizophrenia), and depression in 1872 at the age of 38.

A genuinely tragic figure, Kivi’s downfall offers juicy material for 20th Century operatic treatment and is a good role for a strong dramatic baritone. Jorma Hynninen, for whom the role was written, fits the bill perfectly. A long-time operatic collaborator with Rautavaara, Hynninen is a master of the composer’s lyrical idiom and a fine actor.

Rautavaara’s 1996 three act opera opens with a brief prologue, set near the conclusion of the protagonist’s demise. Act I proper begins as a flashback to the young Kivi (well sung by Ville Rusanen) feeling his oats and declaring his commitment to depicting the Finnish People warts and all, their crude language, heavy drinking, and gruff character naked and unexpurgated. He is surrounded by his two women, his considerably older patroness Charlotta (Riikka Rantanen) and her pretty, if air-headed, blonde pupil Hilda (Pauliina Linnosaari). All is not merry, though, since Aleksis has a jealous alter ego in the Professor August Ahlqvist, intentionally given a speaking role owing to what the composer regards as his inherent lack of musicality (played to the hilt by actor Jenne Reminkainen). Ahlqvist will have none of Kivi’s realist aesthetic, insisting instead on the duty of art to teach man “what should be”, rather than “what is”. His disgust at the rabble’s abuse of the Finnish language might sound familiar to readers of these pages. The act closes with Charlotta thinking better of her budding lust for artist Aleksis, and she leaves him after advising her pupil to leave him as well.

Act II opens with the older Kivi asking the powerful Ahlqvist for aid in getting his works published. Not a chance! He tears up the manuscripts and throws Aleksis a penny to go drinking with. Act III finds the destitute Aleksis alone, drunk and delusional, tortured by the specter of Ahlqvist, assorted characters of his own invention, and apparitions of his past. An Epilogue finds Aleksis at death’s door in a mental institution, begging for peace. He sees himself revisiting his youth and sings a duet with it (a neat touch). The moving, almost Wagnerian finale is set to words that were also set by Sibelius.

Rautavaara based his libretto on texts by Kivi himself, as well as by merciless critic Ahlqvist. They are set in a basically tonal, lyrical style, suitably dramatic sometimes, and are constructed with what amounts to set pieces in the traditional operatic sense. The production is austere, since this is essentially a chamber opera. Groups and spare characters are wheeled around on dollies by “the eight brother” (an extra “Young Finn”: see below), a “dancing role” (Timo Saari) symbolizing, I suppose, Kivi’s active subconscious, or, more likely, his psychosis.

Pekka Milonoff’s direction is more clever than consistently effective…Singing is generally excellent…The piece is worth seeing…subtitling is clear; sound is excellent.

Kevin Filipski
The Flip Side, April 2011

Finland’s Einojuhani Rautavaara is one of our best living composers, and his superb operas run the gamut from a Van Gogh bio to nationalistic subjects like this brilliantly realized musical dramatization of the life of Finland’s national writer, Aleksis Kivi, who died at age 38 in 1872. Taking a cue from Kivi’s writings, Rautavaara cannily weaves past, present and fantasy into a mesmerizing sound world that takes the measure of an artist’s rich but sadly short life. In this superb 2010 Helsinki staging, Jorma Hynninen and Ville Rusanen skillfully share the difficult role of Kivi, while Pekka Milonoff’s striking staging breathes life into Kivi’s literary and personal lives, and Rautavaara’s intense, accessible music sounds better than ever under the baton of conductor Mikko Franck. The bonus feature, The Making of Aleksis Kivi, includes interviews with Hynninen, Milonoff, Franck and a frail-looking Rautavaara.

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group