Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Email Password  
Not a subscriber yet?  
Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

John W Barker
American Record Guide, November 2011

BACH, C.P.E.: Sinfonias, Wq. 182 and 183, H. 657-666 (Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach Chamber Orchestra, Haenchen) Phoenix443
BACH, C.P.E.: Flute Concertos (Haupt, Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach Chamber Orchestra, Haenchen) Phoenix446
BACH, C.P.E.: Oboe Concertos / BACH, J.C.: Oboe Concerto in F major (Glaetzner, Pommer) Phoenix449
BACH, C.P.E.: Organ Concertos, Wq. 34 and 35 (Munch, Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach Chamber Orchestra, Haenchen) Phoenix450
BACH, C.P.E.: Clavichord Sonatas (Nicholson) Phoenix451
BACH, C.P.E.: Flute Sonatas (Haupt, Thalheim, Pank) Phoenix452
BACH, C.P.E.: Vocal Works (Rheinische Kantorei, Das Kleine Konzert, Max) Phoenix453
BACH, C.P.E.: Auferstehung und Himmelfahrt Jesu (Die) / Gott hat den Herrn auferweckt (Schlick, Pregardien, Schwarz, Elliott, Max) Phoenix456

The very positive judgements I made in the earlier reviews still stand. The performances here are very strong and hold up quite well even to later competition (as in the symphonies and concertos). The sonics remain thoroughly satisfying. To be sure, booklet notes are sparse, and vocal texts are given only in the original German.

I hope that Phoenix will go on and revive more of its fine contributions to the swelling discography of this important composer.

Carla Rees
MusicWeb International, August 2011

This disc forms part of Phoenix Edition’s C.P.E. Bach Edition. Originally recorded in 1982, the sound quality is good, with a clear flute sound and an effective balance between flute and accompanying instruments. The acoustic of the recording venue is ideal for this repertoire, lending a gentle and warm reverb to the sound.

The sonatas are arranged here chronologically, making for an interesting overview of C.P.E.’s compositional style. The first sonata, the G major WQ134 was composed in 1735, and like most of the works on the disc has a three movement slow-fast-fast form. The main themes have a distinctive character, featuring dotted rhythms, triplets and a sense of well-honed melodic simplicity.

The E minor sonata has some distinctive baroque features in its compositional style, and one can detect the influence of J.S. Bach. The opening adagio radiates poise and lyricism, while the elegant Menuet with Variations is played at a relatively fast pace, but with a good sense of style.

The second G major sonata, WQ127 was one of three on this disc which are likely to have been written either for Quantz or for his patron, Frederick the Great. The first movement possesses a gentle singing style, and the performance is highly convincing. The mood becomes lighter as the work progresses, and the final dance movement has a lilting feel. The D major sonata, WQ 129 is generally brighter, with sparkling melodies and flowing triplet motifs in the final movement. The minor-key WQ128 is the longest of the six on this disc and makes lovely use of dynamics and beautifully crafted phrases. The opening Andante is expressively played with rich tone and sombre concentration. The second movement contrasts well, with fast moving finger movement executed with evenness and clear articulation. The finale is an elegant dance-style movement with variations all played with charm.

The final work in this collection is the well known Hamburger Sonata, composed much later than the other works here, in 1786. The difference is immediately obvious, and there is a much stronger sense of the Classical style than the Baroque. The Sonata has just two movements, and the opening Allegretto is played with an enjoyable sense of lightness and some well-conceived ornamentation in the harpsichord part. Eckart Haupt brings out the simplicity of the line very well, and allows the music space to breathe. The second movement is unhurried, and somewhat slower than I am used to, with a tempo variation bringing out the character of the different sections. There is a strong sense of personality that comes through in this interpretation, which makes for a wholly convincing performance.

Overall, the playing on this disc is consistently of a high standard, and delivers uncomplicated interpretations of well written music. Haupt’s flute sound is rich and clear, and free from imposing vibrato. The playing is expressive and well phrased, and the continuo is solid and reliable throughout, with elegance and poise well to the fore.

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group