Classical Music Home

Welcome to Naxos Records

Keyword Search
 Classical Music Home > Naxos Album Reviews

Album Reviews

See latest reviews of other albums...

Cinemusical, January 2012

HALFFTER, E.: Carmen [film score] (Frankfurt Radio Symphony, Fitz-Gerald) 8.572260
HUPPERTZ, G.: Metropolis (Strobel) C5066

Best Golden Age Releases of 2011

The oldest of these is Gottfried Huppertz fascinating score for Lang’s Metropolis (1927) in a fully-restored and lovingly performed release on Capriccio…The music is filled with a fascinating blend of modernism, Romanticism, and is a great window on the styles of music popular at the time of the film’s release. The release of a 1926 score for Carmen by Ernesto Halffter on Naxos is also a great example of early original film scoring. It was quite a surprise to get two such treasures in a single year. © 2012 Cinemusical Read complete review

Mark Koldys
American Record Guide, November 2011

It’s a wild, exhilarating ride, probably a bit over the top (like the film itself), but an irresistible wallow for anyone who enjoys the Strauss-Korngold idiom as much as I do. Frank Strobel leads a dynamic, impassioned performance that is played to near-perfection by the Berliners.

To read the complete review, please visit American Record Guide online.

Bob McQuiston
Classical Lost and Found, July 2011

Classical Lost and Found Best Find for 2011

Even after the painstaking 2001 restoration of director Fritz Lang’s (1890–1976) 1927 legendary classic Metropolis, film buffs had to settle for a version less twenty-two minutes that were believed to be irretrievably lost. But in 2008 a miracle happened when the missing footage showed up in the vaults of an Argentine film company. The challenge then was to properly integrate it back into the movie. And to make a long story short (see the informative album notes, or better still the documentaries included with the earlier DVD and later Blu-ray restored versions of the film), it was the existing, meticulously annotated manuscripts and printed parts of German composer Gottfried Huppertz’s (1881–1937) complete score composed in 1926 that made this possible.

In the process all these tidbits were reconstituted under the supervision of film music expert Frank Strobel (b. 1966), whom many will remember for his highly acclaimed releases of Alfred Schnittke’s (1934–1998) movie scores…He’s also our conductor here, and along with the Capriccio Records’ production staff, now treats us to this immaculately laid out, world premiere recording of an extended suite distilled from the original Metropolis motion picture score.

Unlike most movie music, this can stand on its own! Brilliant orchestration that includes extensive percussion as well as some support from the organ, and the use of unifying leitmotifs hold the listener’s attention without the music needing any visual sustenance. A colorful late romantic score incorporating impressionistic, expressionistic and jazz elements, it undoubtedly served as an example to such European expatriate Hollywood composers as Max Steiner (1888–1971), Erich Wolfgang Korngold (1897–1957) and Franz Waxman (1906–1967).

Presented in the same order as they appear on screen, all of the cues are individually banded, and fall into three tableaus corresponding to the film’s tripartite structure. Highlights in the opening “Auftakt” (“Prelude”) include the ecstatic Metropolis main title (EM) [track-1], as well as some machine music [track-2] not too far removed from Alexander Mosolov’s (1900–1973) The Iron Foundry (1926–28) composed about the same time.

There’s also a lovely melting melody (LM) [track-5] characterizing Maria, who’s the leading female protagonist. This will recur, and might be considered a counterpart of Wagner’s (1813–1883) “Redemption through Love” motif in The Ring Cycle (1869–1876).

Other cues of note in the first part include the Dies Irae (DI), which will surface on several occasions, followed by a terrific 1920s dance music sequence (DM) [track-8]. One wonders whether John Williams (b. 1932) knew the mysterious machine-men number [track-10] when he wrote the score for Close Encounters of the Third Kind (1977).

The second tableau, “Zwischenspiel” (“Interlude”), begins with a moving DI-laced, organ-enhanced cathedral cue [track-16]. It’s followed by some spooky laboratory music [tracks-17 through 20] presaging Franz Waxman’s score for The Bride of Frankenstein (1935). There’s also a radiant, heroic idea (RH) representing Freder, who’s the main male protagonist [track-17, beginning at 00:57]. The concluding selections [tracks-21 through 23] are an ear-catching blend of DM, RH, and DI rolled into a final rollicking dance of death made all the more sinister by the presence of a skeletal xylophone and funereal organ.

With the title “Furioso” (“Violent”), the final tableau begins anxiously [track-24] with references to “La Marseillaise” [track-25, beginning at 00:03] signifying the revolutionary activities of workers in the movie. The music builds mechanistically to a belligerent climax [tracks-25 through 31] with frequent references to RH. But order is finally restored, and it ends ecstatically with references to RH, LM and EM [track-32] underpinning the conclusion of a silver screen extravaganza you’ll never forget!

Superior in content to what’s been available before, film music guru Frank Strobel was not only the guiding light behind this extended symphonic synthesis of the original score, but also conducts the Berlin Radio Symphony Orchestra (RSB) in this definitive performance of it. The spontaneity and emotional fervor he gets from the RSB musicians breathe new life into Huppertz’ inspired music.

Done in the Berlin Radio’s Saal 1, the recording projects a wide soundstage in a controlled acoustic. Sounding more like a Hollywood studio productions, clarity is not one of this release’s strong points. On the other hand there is a sonic homogeneity which adds to the emotional intensity of the score. Consequently what the disc lacks from the audiophile standpoint, it makes up for musically.

Naxos Records, a member of the Naxos Music Group